Chapter 18: Release

“The trick isn’t to win battles, it’s to let your opponents lose them.”

Aretha the Raven, Nicaean general

General Sacker came to meet me with a company of a hundred heavies and three lines of mages, the lot of them glittering with at least half a dozen defensive enchantments and shield spells at the tip of their hands. Well, would you look at. The Rebel Legions had grasped the reality that I might be somewhat cross at them. It was almost like they’d taken my coin and supplies for years before turning on me at the first opportunity. I wasn’t going to be forgetting that, or any other of their small slights.

“Hail, Black Queen.”

A mere twenty knight stood fanned out behind me. What need did I have for a larger escort than that?

“Sacker,” I said. “Fancy seeing you here.”

The goblin general had only walked up to the edge of the defensive enchantments and not a step further. I would have been offended by that if I hadn’t seriously considered slaughtering the entire contingent and ripping her plans out of her mind on the ride here. Only the certainty that it would push the rebels to allying with the Black Knight, however temporarily, had stayed my hand.

“You were warned of our march,” General Sacker replied. “We have dealt openly with you.”

“Debatable at best,” I flatly replied. “But let’s pretend I buy that, just for a moment. Keep up that alleged streak and tell me what you lot came here to do.”

“We aim to engage in talks with Marshal Nim,” Sacker said. “We have no intention of fighting you save if you force our hand.”

I snorted. General Mok’s plan to talk the Black Knight into deposing Malicia was still their play, then. They were fools if they thought it would get them anywhere. Nim was in deep with the Tower, she wasn’t going to defect now. Malicia would string them along until she no longer had a use for them, a situation I could only assume was imminent.

“And your stance regarding Sepulchral’s forces?” I asked.

“If arrangement is reached with the Black Knight, there will be either surrender or war,” Sacker said. “If not, the situation remains fluid. Regardless, we will not attack unless first provoked.”

Mhm. Then they weren’t all in on Mok’s plan yet. The vanguard in the northern Moule Hills was being used as threat on the flank of the Loyalist Legions, one they had no intention of removing before a deal was struck with the Black Knight. An alliance with the Rebel Legions wasn’t on the table – wouldn’t be unless Marshal Nim refused their entreaties outright, which she wouldn’t because she wasn’t a fucking idiot – so there was no point in aiming for that. I could, though, aim for a smaller concession.

“Then I’ll ask for your promise to stand aside should I intervene to prevent Marshal Nim wiping out the vanguard,” I said. “If not your help outright, which I would take as a sign of good faith doing much to restore your trustworthiness in my eyes.”

She hesitated.

“They are a rebel force,” General Sacker hedged. “The Black Knight’s duty is clear.”

I met her eyes and let all pleasantness drip down from my face.

“My tolerance has limits,” I said, tone so very mild.

“We are not in your service,” the goblin general snorted.

“No,” I replied, “but so far you have toed the line when it came to being my enemy. You might want to consider the price of crossing it, before you offer me another half-hearted platitude.”

“I am a general of-”

“You were a general,” I coldly interrupted. “Now you’re a vagrant that twice bit the hands feeding you. You’re out of chances, Sacker. With me, with the Tower, with everybody else.”

“Threats will not sway me, girl,” General Sacker said.

I let Night billow in my veins, coming quicker for the anger in my blood.

“A threat?” I laughed. “Do you honestly think your little spells would stop me if I wanted you all dead? If I wanted to rip out every secret from your head and make them dance before my eyes?  It’s not a threat when I warn you, Sacker. You are not strong enough for my words to be hypothetical. If you get in my way, I will fucking step on you.”

I leaned forward.

“So I’m going to ask you again,” I said. “I want your promise to stand aside, should I intervene to prevent the Black Knight from wiping out Sepulchral’s vanguard.”

Still she hesitated, and a ring of red light formed high above me as Night kept coming to me. I ripped it out of the sky without even bothering to look.

“So long as no deal has been struck with the Black Knight, you have our promise,” General Sacker finally said.

“Good,” I harshly smiled.

“You are not making allies with your words, girl,” the goblin said.

“And still I somehow seem to have more than you lot,” I replied.

I cocked my head to the side.

“And Sacker, one last thing?” I added.

She watched me expectantly.

“Call me girl again and I’ll make you eat your own tongue,” I calmly told her.

Somehow, I saw, the calm gave her more pause than my anger had.

The Rebel Legions did two things the day they blew into our increasingly crowded battlefield. The first was send envoys to both myself and the Black Knight. The second was throw their hat in the ring, so to speak. The Loyalist Legions and my Army of Callow had dug trenches and raised palisades along two thirds of the length of the valley between the hills, all the way to the road, but the deserters sent their sappers downhill the moment they had a camp up and began digging a trench of their own. Facing mine and Nim’s, vertical to our horizontal.

“They’re digging a hundred feet past crossbow range, both ours and the Legions’,” General Zola informed us at council. “Sapper-General Pickler believes their fortifications will end up in a thin crescent facing our lines.”

“We’ll need to raise our own trenches facing theirs,” I sighed. “Or they’ll be able to flank us at will.”

It would turn our fortifications into a straight corner with one side facing the Loyalist Legions and the other the Rebel ones, while the Black Knight’s trench would end up at a much wider angle. Given their more numerous sappers, though, I didn’t anticipate them losing much of a step.

“We’re getting boxed in,” Grandmaster Talbot said. “With all these walls and trenches the Order will be made useless.”

“We can’t prevent them for raising fortifications of their own without forcing a battle,” Aisha said. “One at which we will be at a severe disadvantage, should the Black Knight reinforce them.”

Which she probably would. The deserters were still at a full force, thirteen thousand and fresh. The Army of Callow numbered a little under thirteen thousand, now, and Nim’s legions should be around twenty or twenty-one thousand. That battle would see us outnumbered more than two to one while flanked, which was a recipe for disaster. We couldn’t afford to start that fight.

“We do nothing,” I said, the words bitter against my tongue. “To them, at least. Our sappers need to prepare our flank for the possibility of assault now.”

It was out of my hands, now. All I could hope was that my enemies did not yet band together. The day passed quickly enough, laden with bad news, but the following warning ended up just as darkened. Scribe had requested the war council gather, which was rare enough I did not think twice about granting the request. What she had to say was not long, but it still hit hard.

“It cost me most of my agents within Sepulchral’s main host, but I have found out who plans her campaign for her,” Scribe said.

I laid back into my seat, already sensing this was not pleasant news.

“Instructions are received by letter, which are read out loud over scrying ritual,” Eudokia said. “The physical letters eventually make their way to Sepulchral herself, however, and my people were able to forge a decent copy of one before fleeing camp.”

She set down a letter on the table, which aside from having calligraphy small and cramped did not particularly evoke anything in me. Juniper, though, breathed in sharply.

“This is Grem One-Eye’s handwriting,” Scribe said. “He has been planning Sepulchral’s campaign for her from captivity in Ater.”

I grimaced. Well, fuck. Just what we needed, another marshal in the mix. My fingers clenched, then unclenched. Wrong way to think about this, I decided. Grem wouldn’t have had the pull to do this on his own, someone had to be helping him. Hells, someone had to have asked him to do this because otherwise I couldn’t see him helping Abreha Mirembe. And only two people were in position to do it, Malicia and my father. It didn’t fit Malicia, though, her way of doing things. Even if she’d been helping Sepulchral stay afloat with good advice, she would have cut off the flow now. She could no longer afford game this elaborate.

So it meant I had, at last, found the first trace of what my father was up to in Kala.

That somewhat improved my mood, but it passed quickly. While I’d been lost in thought I’d not been paying attention to the table, which only claimed my attention again when there was a ripple in the assembled council. Juniper had gotten to her feet.

Without a word, she walked out of the tent and did not return.

Once more I found the Marshal of Callow standing beneath a sycamore.

The same as last time, a bone-dry skeleton of a tree hollowed out inside. Dead and dying, the limbs having yet to catch up to the emptiness at the heart of it. Juniper’s escort had stayed far, as ordered, and as I limped past them across the dusty ground I found my eye dragged above. Sunset was painting the sky in layers, just like the stones of the hills to the west: the dark blue of night high above, with a distant moon, but then it lightened. Yellowed. Only to deepen once more, orange and red and at last a rich purple. Day died and its death throes shifted across the stone and dust, shade cutting in fluid slices as it swallowed up Creation in a never-sated maw. The Wasteland, for all its many dangers, was capable of eerie beauty at times.

Juniper was not leaning against the tree. I saw that first, even as I approached her. I had thought to find here the same hunched and self-loathing creature that’d been wearing the skin of one of my oldest friends for over a sennight, but this was… different. Her back might not be straight, but she was not sagging like withered vine. Instead she stood there with a lost and thoughtful look on her face, looking straight west. I followed her gaze, founding nothing more than the sappers of the Rebel Legions at work digging their own trench and palisade. They were skilled hands, well-drilled for all that they had deserted the Tower’s service. The three generals leading them had kept them disciplined.

I hesitated to break the silence. I’d found what I’d thought I would, and I was not sure I wanted to interrupt… whatever this was. For all the intensity of the Hellhound’s gaze, I had of late seen in her fragility that had me staying my hand. As I wrestled with my doubts, she came to a decision of her own. Her voice was rasping when she spoke. Dry, and she licked her chops before doing it.

“The Scribe, she said that Sacker’s in command among the deserters,” Juniper said. “Is it true?”

I hummed.

“Can’t be sure,” I admitted. “But the Jacks heard the same thing. I think Mok has more pull when it comes to strategic decisions, since he has the biggest army, but that Sacker’s the lead for tactics.”

Her eyes never left the sappers digging to the west. I bit my lip, then cast aside my hesitation. It wasn’t doing me any good.

“They tell me you’ve been here more than two hours,” I said. “Have you been looking at them the whole time?”

The Hellhound laughed. It was a low, rumbling thing. Not quite amused or happy, more like a… release. Vented feeling.

“Yeah, I have,” Juniper said. “Because there’s this…”

She shook her head.

“She was like an aunt to me, Sacker,” the orc said.

I did remember. It felt like a lifetime ago, but I remembered. I’d never seen her as embarrassed as she had been when I’d first seen her meet her mother and almost-aunt fuss over her after she became a legate. It’d been a memorable sight.

“Auntie Sacks,” I idly said.

“She used to tell me stories,” Juniper distantly said. “When I was small, Catherine. To make me go to sleep. That was all back in Summerholm, before I went home to be raised by my father. Goblin stories about gore and raids and little girls that got gobbled up for being too slow or too dim.”

“She seemed close to your mother,” I said.

I’d never grown to know either more than shallowly, but it’s been obvious to be even when I’d been young.

“She was probably Mom’s closest friend in the world,” she replied. “She spent more years of her life with Sacker at her side than she did my own father. It showed. Goblins aren’t usually… good with children. Sacker was making an effort.”

“She seems to have made an impression on you,” I said.

Juniper flashed pale fangs at the deepening night.

“She did,” the Hellhound said. “But not just for the stories. Did you ever hear she was meant to rise to Marshal in Ranker’s place when she retired?”

“There were rumours,” I acknowledged. “You know, back before…”

I gesture vaguely, meaning a great many things but not in particular. She snorted in amusement.

“I looked up to her for that,” Juniper said. “Even more than I did my mother, because my mother was never going to rise higher than she had. It wasn’t like Istrid Knightsbane I wanted to be when I grew up, Catherine. It was like Grem and Ranker and Nim. The Marshals. And Sacker, she had the stuff. The marshals knew it, so the Carrion Lord. If things had turned out different, it could be her serving as the Tower’s greatest captain instead of Nim.”

“A lot of things could have gone differently,” I said.

My hand half-rose to the cloth covering the eye sloppiness had cost me before I forced it down. Some mistakes stayed with you longer than others. I found Juniper’s gaze had moved to me, catching sight of the aborted movement, and I flushed in embarrassment. Those kinds of regrets I preferred kept unseen from even my friends.

“It’s an eye, Catherine,” Juniper said. “Just an eye. You could lose both and still be who you are. And that’s what eats at me. When did you know?”

“Know what?”

Her gaze was alight with something I could not quite name.

“Who you were,” Juniper gravelled. “We’ve hung titles around your neck like necklaces at a summer fair, Warlord. Countess. Squire. Arch-heretic of the East. Black Queen, Queen of Lost and Found, of Winter, of the Hunt. First Under the Night. But before that, when did you know?”

Half a dozen answers, some flippant and others rote, came to the tip of my tongue. I could not get any of them out, not meeting her eyes with my last remaining one. Seeing the cast of her face in the last gaps of the day, the despair and the hunger that burned in her eyes. I did love her, Juniper. My own Hellhound. As deeply as I did the Woe. I’d loved her as the hard-eyed foe I had to overcome to prove myself worthy of my father’s tutelage, when we’d both been children, and I loved her now as the woman who’d built a kingdom and an army with me. So I stayed silent, for a long moment, and told her the truth.

“In the Everdark,” I quietly said. “There was…”

I swallowed. I’d never spoken of this to anyone, not even Hakram. The words did not come easy. Was there a way in any language ever made that I could truly explain what they had been, the last moments of the battle in Great Strycht?

“I lost,” I finally said, tone quiet. “They carved me open, Juniper, and all the power and the death and the madness I’d gorged myself on came pouring back out.”

I looked down and found my hand was shaking a bit. I had come to understand the Sisters, and they me, but that had been after. After.

“It was like blinders went off my eyes,” I murmured. “And Gods, but I had done so many horrible things. More of them were all I could see ahead, and I was just so fucking tired. So I went down.”

I closed my fingers into a fist, to kill the tremors.

“And I stayed down, waiting to choke in the snow.”

I heard the sharp intake of breath.

“But I didn’t,” I murmured. “It took too long, you see. Snow melted enough I could breathe. And I still wanted to stay down, to sleep, but I just…”

I laughed, as mirthlessly as she had.

“It was a choice,” I said. “And there was nothing weighing the balance either way. So I ask myself, why not?”

I tightened my cloak around my shoulders, shivering.

“And then?” Juniper quietly asked.

“And then I got up,” I softly smiled. “And I think that’s what stayed with me, Juniper. The even balance and the question and the choice I made. And it’s gone to shit since, you know. Death and doom and the age falling down on our heads. And every day the same choice is there waiting to be made: lie down…”

“Or stand up,” the Hellhound finished.

I nodded.

“I’ve stayed on my feet,” I said. “I will, until I am either victorious or I die. I think that’s what left of me, when you whittle away the rest.”

Juniper looked away.

“I thought it’d be victory,” the Hellhound admitted.

“It’s never the victories that stay with you,” I tiredly said.

Large fingers laid against the dead wood.

“No,” the Marshal of Callow said, “I guess not.”

A moment passed.

“You’re looking west again.”

“Ranker’s dead,” Juniper quietly said. “But Sacker’s here. Nim is here. And Grem uses Sepulchral’s army. Everyone who is or could be a Marshal of Praes.”

I studied her, but her expression was hard to make out and her eyes stayed west.

“There’s this thing I see, Catherine,” she confessed. “The lay of it. Two hours I’ve watched the sappers, how quick they work. How quick the work will be done. And I know how quickly Nim’s will work, and ours and…”

“And what?” I quietly asked.

“And there is a box,” the Marshal of Callow said. “Where the battle will happen. I see it. It’s where it’ll all happen and we can shape it.”

I could smell it the air, now. Victory. Yet Creation did not shiver, fate did not ripple like a lake in the wind, because this was not the writ of any Gods. It was just Juniper of the Red Shields, looking at a dusty field in the middle of nowhere and being the woman I’d glimpsed in her at seventeen.

“You want to fight,” I said.

It was not a question.

“Sacker hasn’t seen it,” Juniper said, sounding disbelieving. “She can’t have, not if she’s raising those walls. Sacker hasn’t seen it, and she could have been a Marshal.”

Large fingers clawed at the thin bark of the dying sycamore. She turned to me.

“I could be wrong,” she told me, tone anguished. “I could be just seeing what’s not there. I’ve… these have not been good days, Catherine, and I did not stand up in the face of them. I need you to know that I could be wrong.

I would have answered, but she was not done. The words were spilling out of her like broken barrel.

“I feel like my entire life I’ve been drawing a bow,” Juniper said. “And ever since I’ve been your marshal, I’ve just… stood there. And my hand’s been trembling. But this? This place, this box, these foes?”

The hand left the tree and she pushed away, straightening her back.

“I can release the arrow,” Juniper of the Red Shields said, pleaded. “I can win this. Please.”

And I could have taken her by the arm, brought her close and told her that she did not need to win back my trust because she’d never lost it. But I knew, sure as dawn, that it was not what she wanted. Needed. And I was my father’s daughter, so I offered her the very same grace I was once offered. My wrist snapped out and metal slapped against my palm.

I handed her a knife, pommel first.

“If you mean the words,” I replied, “commit. Carve them.”

Incomprehension, first, but I saw her eyes clear as she matched my gaze. I did not mean the plea, or the apology that came unspoken with it. Those were between us. What I wanted from her was conviction. The Hellhound leaned close to the tree, reaching inside, and carved. The strokes shook, at first, but grew certain. Her hand did not tremble. And when she withdrew, deep in the hollow of a dead tree waited these words: Marshal Juniper wins here. I smiled, startled.

“Here?” I asked, amused. “Exactly?”

“This tree is where we win,” the Marshal of Callow said, tone even, “and everyone else loses.”

She offered me back the knife, pommel first. I took it.

“Let’s go home,” I said. “It’s getting late.”

“Yeah,” Juniper said, eyes red. “Let’s go home, Catherine.”

We’d left alone. We came back together.

“First, we shape the box,” the Marshal of Callow said.

It was a surprisingly simple thing, when it came down do it. We had our palisade and trench from Kala Hills to the half-road, so the only way to go was south. The assumption in my head had been that it’d turn into a right angle facing the Rebel Legion line, but Juniper had seen otherwise. Sacker and her fellows had been clever in putting themselves between two forces that did not want to fight them, forcing them to dig in and confirm their position of kingmaker of this battlefield. The downside, though, was that the sappers of the Rebel Legions needed to dig their trench in both directions simultaneously. So we took advantage of that.

We began building westwards instead of south, a sloping line of defence headed towards Moule Hills. Immediately the Rebel Legions began trying to force us back by cutting through our path, keeping at the same distance neither of us had yet dared to break, but when they focused their efforts south the Loyalist Legions began pushing at them instead. Nim wasn’t any more interested in giving them leverage than we were, after all.

“The slopes grow steeper further south of Moule Hills,” the Hellhound said. “That leaves only a narrow passage through which they can move troops into the valley, if they attack. That will shape where they attack.”

“Which we don’t want them to,” I pointed out.

“Indeed. So while we raise our works we have to delay,” the Marshal of Callow said. “We must maintain the stalemate until Sepulchral’s main host arrives.”

She had notions as how that should be done, of course. The first was to put the Loyalist Legions on the backfoot by poisoning the source of water they’d been using since we cut them off from their supply lines: Nioqe Lake.

“We don’t have anything that can poison a lake that large,” I pragmatically said.

I’d pretty much kill the town of Risas as well, but I was less broken up about that when they’d been providing guides to Legion skirmishers. I’d offer them safe passage south through the territory I controlled, but I wasn’t going to weep about them being driven out if we did it. Which I wasn’t sure we could.

“We do,” Juniper grunted, “for the same reason that we had to use that lake for water. Arcadian water can’t be safely drunk.”

A hundred knights, Masego and myself went for a ride. We tore through Akua’s attempts to stop us and I opened a gate in the sky, making Nioqe Lake a third larger and entirely unusable for water supplies.

“Then slow the deserters,” the Marshal of Callow said. “The moment their walls are up they can afford to start provoking us and strongarm the Black Knight.”

She spent half a day with Pickler out in the field, studying the eastern slopes of Moule Hills, before asking me for Archer and the Huntress. Ballistas were moved, and then fired at the hillside exactly five times with the Named as spotters. The ensuing landslide didn’t kill anyone that we saw, but it did drop down a least of tone of rock right in the middle of the way of the Rebel Legions. They’d have to clear them out before they could get back to work.

“So we hit the Loyalists, after that,” I guessed.

“It’s necessary and they had to be last,” the Hellhound said. “By now they’ve used all their sudes to match our wall and the deserters’. But we don’t want them to be able to keep fortifying over the next few days, they would encircle Sepulchral’s camp with walls entirely. Thankfully, their wood reserves were used to make the ring of forts around the Aksum camp, so they are now entirely dependent on the wood cut down in Kala Hills.”

“So what do we do, drive them out?” I asked.

“That would be too costly,” Juniper replied. “There is another way. It hasn’t rained in days. All you have to do, Catherine, is live up to your reputation.”

We set fire to the damned hills. Masego and I with large columns of blackflame, but it wasn’t only us. Indrani and Alexis shot fire arrows, a raiding party with Squire and Apprentice started a swath with torches and fire spells. The blaze got out of control when the wind turned, burnt a chunk of the hills under our control as well, but for the better part of the day the wind had blown north. The Legions weren’t going to get anything but ash out of those hills.

“The Black Knight will dismantle Ogarin for spare parts,” the Marshal of Callow noted, “but that will take time and the townsfolk will resist. It should buy us long enough.”

It did.

Sepulchral had been six days as well, and we kept the stalemate going just long enough. Our wall was anchored on the slopes of Moule Hills, facing that of the Rebel Legions, while to the north the Black Knight had hemmed them in as well. Envoys had gone back and forth between those camps, but no alliance against the Army of Callow had emerged. We’d kept them on the backfoot until Sepulchral arrived from the west with the rest of her twenty-thousand strong army. The Loyalist Legions had not finished their encirclement of the camp up in Moule Hills, and so they were forced to evacuate the sole fort in the way of Sepulchral linking her forces together late in the sixth day.

And so, at least, everyone was here.

“My agents in the Rebel Legion camp tell me that the talks with Marshal Nim are souring,” Scribe told me the same day, in my tent.

“She’s still not budging?” I asked.

“She has promised to extract of Malicia promises to make suborning officers of the Legions of Terror with mind control spells,” Scribe said, “but she still refuses to turn on the Tower in any significant manner. Now there is division among their generals. Sacker is pushing for their force to declare in favour of Amadeus as Dread Emperor, but Mok is strongly opposed. He instead argues that if further concessions are extracted from Malicia, safeguarding the sanctity of the Legions, their reasons for breaking with the Tower no longer exist.”

“Jaiyana Seket?” I asked.

“Hedging,” Scribe grimaced. “There’s not telling which way she’ll end up leaning.”

I breathed out. General Mok was arguing to rejoin Malicia’s cause, essentially. And he’d never bothered to pretend he was anything but hostile to my presence in Praes, or indeed the Grand Alliance’s concerns about the Dread Empire. I’d warned them that my tolerance had limits.

“Have assassin kill Mok,” I said. “Frame Sepulchral for it if you can.”

“That should be-” Scribe began, but she was interrupted when Vivienne blew into my tent.

I cocked an eyebrow at my successor, who was looking rather harried.

“Viv?”

“Trouble,” she said. “I have a fresh word from the Jacks. General Mok was killed an hour ago.”

I glanced at Scribe, but she shook her head. I supposed not even the Webweaver worked that fast.

“Where’s the trouble?” I asked.

“General Seket got killed as well and they caught the people who supposedly killed both,” Vivienne said.

I swore furiously.

“They caught Jacks, didn’t they?” I asked.

She nodded.

“It’s… bad, Catherine,” she said. “There’s been brawls in their camp, people are saying this is a coup by Sacker done with our backing. That she’s planning to sell out Praes to the Grand Alliance.”

I swore again.

“If I may hazard a guess,” Scribe mildly said, “the figurehead of this belief will be the senior legate for either Mok or Jaiyana Seket?”

Vivienne looked startled.

“Mok,” she confirmed.

I leaned back into my seat, closing my eyes and rubbing the bridge of my nose. Well, that was a particularly convenient turn for the Tower wasn’t it?

“Fuck,” I said. “Malicia played us.”

She’d whipped the deserters into a frenzy against us just before a battle was to erupt and the seniormost officer with a clean reputation was most likely in her pocket. Maybe if there were a few days or a week for things to calm down this could be straightened out, but we wouldn’t get that long. Ten to one odds she had something nasty cooked up for Sepulchral’s army too, I thought.

“Tomorrow we have a battle on our hands,” I plainly said. “We need to pull off your plan tonight, Vivienne. Can it be done?”

She grimaced.

“I would have liked a day or two longer, to make contact with the right people,” she admitted. “But it is not impossible.”

“Then go get your cloak, we move with nightfall,” I said. “I’ll need you to inform Juniper, Scribe, because come dawn the blades will finally come out.”

137 thoughts on “Chapter 18: Release

    • Yep. I have three guesses on just what the next title might be:

      1. Going directly to Follow-Through. That being said, with everything only hitting the fan now, that seems unlikely.
      2. Something involving the arrow in Flight.
      3. An interlude interrupting for the actual battle. Possibly several interludes before we hit Follow-Through.

      If I had to put money on one, I’d do it on number 3 – major battles do tend to lean towards Interludes. Still, there have been surprises before.

      Liked by 8 people

  1. Did Juniper just get a Name? The Marshall of Callow. I wonder if she’s a Hero or a Villain? I expect that historically that would have been an Heroic Name, but she is the Marshall of a villainous Queen, so…

    Liked by 1 person

    • No, I don’t think so. The text explicitly says that creation didn’t ripple and that it wasn’t an act of the gods. A Name would be a bit too out of left field for her at this point. Especially considering she’s an Orc, and how there’s a lot of baggage tied to that.

      Liked by 17 people

    • Nope.
      It’s explicitly said how that’s not the case, even if it pretty much should.

      I had also believed Juniper would come out of this phase of depression, her own personal trial by fire, with a Name. Specifically the Name of Marshal.

      But this is cool too.

      Here, on this field, Juniper of the Red Shields is the Marshal. The genius to beat the geniuses and accomplished veterans of the previous generation.
      But she is not being Named for it, she’s not having the support of Above or Below, this is all her. No mandate of the Gods leaning on the scales, no Aspect, no Providence. Only strategy.

      Liked by 17 people

      • Honestly, I give it fifty fifty odds that she becomes the Marshall after winning a battle involving three more Marshalls. Having it happen before would have been weak, as this was a pivot for the character but the character has been on the back seat for a long time: she needs a deed to claim the Name.

        But it would be cool either way.

        Liked by 8 people

        • She has the story, she has the role, she even has all the ‘claimants’ represented in the battle, but she lacks the will. She doesn’t want to shape the world, just win this battle. Otherwise she’d have the ripple, the weight of a Name that might be.
          I wouldn’t have been upset if this was how she gained a Name -they’ve been built on less- but I don’t think she will.

          Liked by 3 people

          • Meh.
            “Shaping the world” is kind of a fuzzy concept. Squire!Cat wanted to fix the world or die trying, but Squire!Arthur pretty much just wants to be a good knight.
            Both got Named.

            As we were reminded this chapter, Juniper has always wanted to be a Marshal, so she doesn’t lack that will, juts the belief she’s good enough.
            If she wins, she’d likely get that.

            It’s not a given, mind you; I’m just saying it is very much a possibility.

            Liked by 5 people

            • Arthur isn’t a good example- he’s a hero, not a villain. But I mostly agree with you; the Poisoner got a villain Name, and she’s not interested in changing the world, just baking pies and murder. She’d be as happy baking pies for the rest of her life, it’s just that murder pays better.

              Liked by 8 people

              • Yeah, poisoner and grizzled fantassin were both about wanting to the best at their thing, not any greater scope plans, and juniper is right there in wanting to be the best general possible. And given how the marshals have been built up, breaking the armies of 3 different marshals would be just the thing to earn juniper the name.

                Liked by 4 people

                • I don’t think the Grizzled Fantassin is a villain. She’s a mercenary, who works for whoever pays her. It’s part of her Name, as much as fighting is. And I didn’t think she was necessarily the best fantassin when she got the Name, just one of the most experienced on the front lines. If she was a commander type Name, she’d be better served leading a company of Fantassins on one of the fronts, not providing muscle to a Band of Five sent miles from the front line.

                  Liked by 5 people

                • In fact, they weren’t even passionate about it, nor did they want to be the best at it.
                  If anything, it felt more like they were just doing their thing, and Name just started to coalesce in them through a long time without them doing anything extraordinary or special.
                  Then one day they realized they had a Name.
                  Poisoner literally looked at the mirror one day and the realization hit her, while Grizzled Fantassin was sort of brooding while thinking about her life and about how she was now a veteran before she had noticed it.

                  Liked by 4 people

                  • Yeah, it’s about the story, not any kind of internal will / passion, those only matter insofar as they factor into the story.

                    The key point is, the story of a grizzled fantassin or a poisoner resonates with people, they would retell it and find it fun should they hear it. The story of a marshal? Calernia collectively goes “meh” to that, or Grem One-Eye would have been Named.

                    Liked by 2 people

                    • Only two points:

                      •Black calls being Named “imposing your will on Creation,” (can’t find the source, probably paraphrasing) although he may be wrong about this since Namelore is hard to be objective about. Cat says of Vivienne “You’ve got your Role and the will, but you need weight. A story that people will talk about.” Although she picked this up from Black and so if he’s wrong so is she.
                      •Grem was a claimant. It was mentioned when Hakram was 70% of the way to Adjutant. “The last orc to have the potential for a Name was Grem One-Eye, boy. You walk in hallowed company.” (2-11: Report) The implication is that Grem turned down being The Marshal because it would have sparked another civil war. Much in the same way that Akua’s father turned down becoming the Warlock.

                      Otherwise, yes, the Poisoner and Fantassin shoot all of my assumptions about namelore to pieces. I guess my main reason for insisting that Juniper won’t be Named -ever- is the amount of focus her lack of Clamancy has had. Throughout the story, but especially in this last scene. As always I look forward to being wrong, but I feel this is one of my less crackpot theories.

                      Liked by 3 people

                    • * Plenty of stories involve will as a component, i.e. to fit the Role properly you need the will. That doesn’t mean every story is like that. Catherine is talking about Vivienne’s story, which very much involves will.

                      * Amadeus tells Catherine that the difference between people who have Roles and people who don’t is will in Chapter 1. Amadeus also tells Tariq that there is no such thing as teachings of Below in Peers and tells Catherine that it’s okay to want things for herself even though she’s a villain (that condition famously hostile to wanting things for yourself). Amadeus is not so much wrong as, as, he’s an orator. He doesn’t pick things to say based on whether they are true or make internal sense, but only on whether they further his point / fit his agenda.

                      * “Grem was a claimant. It was mentioned when Hakram was 70% of the way to Adjutant. “The last orc to have the potential for a Name was Grem One-Eye, boy. You walk in hallowed company.” (2-11: Report) The implication is that Grem turned down being The Marshal because it would have sparked another civil war.” What makes you think Marshal is the Name Grem was a claimant for? Also you can’t turn down Names. Cordelia’s was a 1 in 1000 case that Augur worked her ass off to arrange and Cat’s still telling her she’s going to get the Name anyway since she claimed the Role with her actions, just in another way. “People can refuse Names at will” is a common myth in the fandom, it’s not actually how it works in-universe. You can only get out of getting a Name by getting out of the groove that’s leading you to getting one. Grem, y’know, kept being Marshal. And I read that reference as Grem having been a claimant to Warlord and going off the rails by going to Black’s side to be Marshal instead. (Akua’s father chose to not do Warlock things, that’s why/how he did not pursude the claim he potentially had. Grem did Marshal things)

                      Anyway yeah Juniper isn’t going to be Named because her role isn’t interesting enough to a layperson to be a Role. She doesn’t do Named things, she does things that are awesome when you’re a specialist that can appreciate them.

                      Liked by 1 person

                    • This is mostly to Shikkarasu: The Name that Grem turned down wasn’t Marshal- it was Warlord. He turned it down by agreeing to be a marshal of Praes under Amadeus as the Black Knight, rather than leading the orcs on an ultimately futile war against Praes. Because if they attacked Praes, and lost, then the orcs would be back where they started; if he became a marshal of the Legions of Terror, and won, orcs get a step closer to equality in Praes.

                      Liked by 4 people

                    • That’s what I think too, though both of you are committing the presentation error of stating speculation as facts, I’m pretty sure we never got elaboraiton on Grem’s claim one way or another.

                      Liked by 3 people

                    • Unles Callow wants to start telling meritocratic military stories, and they start with “the Marshal of Callow is an Orc and she beat three human Praesi Marshals at once, because she’s just that good”.

                      Liked by 1 person

                    • None of them are human. The Black Knight is Marshal Nim, an ogre. General Sacker is the last commander standing in the Rebel Legions, and a goblin- and not a marshal; she didn’t get that promotion. And Marshal Grem One-Eye is also an orc.

                      Liked by 2 people

                    • At this point, it’s been proven that there’s no one absolute formula for a Name to form. Nor a unique ever-present thing for a new Name to emerge or an old Name to be claimed.
                      Many factors can be involved, and both inside and outside the books various have been identified: strong will, weight (which can mean lots of things, from how well-known a story is to how relevant an event is), burning conviction, fame (like Heiress turning into Diabolist because that was the fame she earned or Catherine being about to get the Name of Black Queen because that’s how people called her), and more.

                      Heck, Names can be rejected by the claimant (Akua’s dad and Cordelia), and another person can stop you from getting a Name, (Amadeus preventing Cat from becoming Black Queen), or you can lose a Name because of depression (Viviene) being “killed” (Akua losing Diabolist after becoming a shade, and Cat losing Squire due to being Fae), it can be usurped through ritual (Chider stealing Squire from Cat), or the Gods can take it from you (Amadeus losing Black Knight).

                      You can even have a Name forced into you, like Anaxares’s case.

                      Sabah said “I was born into mine” but that’s a bit vague and open to interpretation, her whole family bloodline is cursed with lycanthropy, so she wasn’t and couldn’t be the only cursed, yet she was the Cursed up until she became Captain.

                      So there are many, many factors at play, both personal and cultural, and thus the presence of some factors do not assure the emergence of a Name, and the absence of a particular one doesn’t mean a Name won’t be obtained.

                      On a meta-level, and ultimately, characters get Names because the author says so XD

                      Like

                    • Story is the universal factor in all of these.

                      You can reject a Name or fail to claim it by not doing the thing a person with the Name’s Role would have done. (As with Akua’s dad, Cordelia and Catherine)

                      You can lose a Name by no longer performing the Role authentically (which happened to both Amadeus and Vivienne)

                      Fame can be a part of the story. Will can be a part of the story. Literally any in-universe factor can be a part of the story, which is why Names are so diverse. Story is the unifying factor it all comes down to.

                      Culture, narrative, how people frame the world for themselves. It’s what shapes Names and empowers them. A Name cannot exist if there’s no cultural impetus for it (WoE).

                      It’s really not that complicated.

                      Like

                  • Eh, grizzled fantassin at least had a, “If I’m going to be a grizzled fantassin I’m going to be *The* grizzled fantassin” line which I took to be a desire to be the best and most accomplished one.

                    Liked by 1 person

            • I think if she pulls this battle off as planned that might be the start of a name, she really needs to get her groove back before she has the conviction to claim a name. These things tend to take a while and there’s been no hints whatsoever of her getting name powers so I don’t see it just popping into existence all of the sudden.

              Liked by 1 person

              • Conviction isn’t a necessary requirement for a Name (newborn baby Sabah!)

                A story is. And Juniper doesn’t have one, not one that resonates in-universe. “I was the daughter of a renowned berserker general and wanted to be less like her and more like the people who stayed on the backline and planned, but I wasn’t sure I was good enough – but then I saw what other marshals didn’t and I got my conviction back” gets a resounding “meh” from people who aren’t also high level officers who appreciate what goes into a battle plan.

                Liked by 1 person

                • You are really nitpicking there.
                  That’s not Juniper’s story.

                  Juniper built up an army nearly from the ground up, a multi-cultural and multi-species army, taking Callowans into Praesi doctrine of war, integrating the now Knight Order into their ranks, and since its foundation, Juniper has led them alongside Catherine through campaigns that would have broken more veteran armies.
                  Battles against hordes of devils, multiple Demons, the armies of the continent, and Arcadia.
                  Juniper is doubting herself because the responsibility on her shoulders is massive, and she has been faced with hard situations and dark days for the past three years, making strategic errors and facing defeat, not to mention what Malicia’s orders did to Juniper. Her depression and doubts make a lot of sense.

                  Because she was facing multiple enemies on all fronts and threats all around from veterans of war and geniuses from all over Calernia, she was on the backfoot against Kairos Theodosian, a man who -however temporarily- could even outplay the Wandering Bard and the Dead King while playing around with the rest of the armies in the field.
                  She rightfully sees that the board is wide and complex and she has faced, is facing, and will continue to face opponents that by any normal logic should be able to crush her. She was having doubts because she is aware of the precarious situation and the magnitude of the opposition.
                  Only now she is finally getting rid of her hesitation and finding her spark again. Noticing that despite the might and wit of the enemies she does not lack that herself. Now she is facing the legends of her home, the men and women she grew up admiring and looking up to, the people that inspired her to be who she is now.

                  And she is going to beat them all.

                  That is the story of Juniper of the Red Shields. the Marshal of Callow.

                  Calling it what you did is a gross oversimplification.

                  Liked by 1 person

            • The problem is that Juniper’s Role does not match the culture she’s in. A supermajority people on Calernia still only cares about commanders when they lead charges, which Juniper doesn’t. Her story isn’t told and won’t be told even if it’s known, people just won’t care that she saw a box, they won’t understand what it means.

              Like

          • It’s not about the will. It’s about the story weight. Like five people total appreciate the gravity of Juniper’s waffling here, literally everyone else would go cross-eyed bored listening to the story of a backline Marshal.

            Like

      • I think the only reason Marshal isn’t a name yet is that there are too many witht he title right now plus is mor elike the role/pattern is forming, Marshal is definedtly become a name in the next generation if you ask me, same way as Captain or the 1 that basically was a commander of the Watch (the one Black killed back as the squire via crowsbow barrage).

        There probably will be subtypes like Marshal fo Callow and anothe rfor Praes, or even ranks like High Marshal.

        Another thing why i think it isn’t 1 right now and will probably emerge in the next generation is that the title of Marshal is gaining weight abroad, every nation on Calernia will respect the title and that will add weight but it is still a process in progress so is basically accumulating

        Liked by 3 people

        • Most people on Calernia will remember these wars as shaped by the politicians and the commanders who actually took point. Amadeus of the Green Stretch, Catherine Foundling, Cordelia Hasenbach, the Blood, Klaus Papenheim. Juniper of the Red Shields isn’t exciting – she’s the one who goes to nap while the battle rages, because her part in it is done.

          There’s no story in a Marshal’s role.

          Like

          • I don’t quite agree with you I mean just look at military sci-fi like legends of the Galactic heroes. It managed to keep me invested for 110 episodes and it was pretty much just a story about a bunch of people making battle plans definitely a genre. Even looking at it from a historical point of you people still remember Moltke the elder or Marianne. And both of their contributions to history were mostly around building battle doctrine rather than leading forces as commanders. There’s definitely a story to Marshalls Maybe not in the old system of names given that was more epic fantasy but in the New World that’s being created I could very much see it

            Liked by 1 person

            • Sure, in a hundred years or so I can picture commander Names emerging. Right now the culture of Calernia is clearly focused otherwise – if only because there’s no shortage of people who are BOTH awesome commanders AND do heroic charges, overshadowing those who are just the first thing.

              Also, I have no idea who either Moltke the elder or Marianne are. I managed to live 27 years a nerd without learning a single fucking thing about them, which brings us back to my point about how most people don’t really retell these stories.

              (Military sci-fi is not a currently existing genre on Calernia. It needs to be in-universe stories, remember? Like when EE shot down the Grey Knight Catherine theories by saying there’s no cultural impetus for the Name Grey Knight anywhere on Calernia)

              Like

              • Yeah I definitely see your point. And I might just be a massive military history nerd with a bunch of friends who are also massive military history nerds so what I consider general knowledge might actually not be that. However for the no cultural story part wasn’t Theodosius the unconquered pretty much just a military commander name. How is thought that he was just fantasy Napoleon or Alexander the Great. I do agree that we’re unlikely to see Juniper get one mostly because if someone was going to get one I think it would’ve been the iron Prince.(good old Clouse was one of my favorite Side characters) But as all of the armies become more professional the role of really good general staff member is going to become a lot more relevant. Which is why one could argue that Juniper could climb at whereas these other commanders current as she is more on the administration side.

                (I mean like I said I’m just playing devils advocate. I would preferred juniper not get a name we need more non-named characters doing awesome shit. As I feel like there are just way too many names running around right now most of which are really cool but don’t get flushed out)

                Liked by 1 person

                • Theodosius the Unconquered was a ruler, which Juniper is not. Battle winning is a black box for most people – they can appreciate that it was awesome how it happened, but there’s little patience/understanding for the details of who did what in the planning stage. So you know the credit for the whole thing tends to go to the seniormost person, who is the one that gets a Name from it if anyone.

                  Like

            • Henry, sorry, you’re loosing me a bit.

              Do you mean Marianne the official semi-naked person of the French Revolution, or someone else?

              Like

              • Marian (I spelled his name wrong forgive my dyslexia)

                He was the guy behind the Marian reforms which essentially turned the Roman army into the legions that we think of today whereas before that they used Astarte and had a completely different organizational structure. Essentially he’s the black of the real world and that he turned the legions into a professional well disciplined fighting force. He’s also famous for being one of the first generals to march on Rome at the head of an army and his rise to power is generally considered the start of the decline of the Roman Republic.

                https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marian_reforms

                Like

    • Nope. That being said, with every single marshal in the theatre of combat fighting the same battle, it’s possible they’re all claimants for the Name of Marshal.

      Liked by 4 people

        • Arguable. Names take a while to form, and they need a ‘groove’ in Creation. There needs to be a Story and a Role. However, that Story doesn’t need to be one that is widely known, else you’d never be able to have secretive Villains with new names. It just needs to resonate with a Role that has fully formed.Given that we know that Grem One-Eye could have been a Named Warlord, it’s likely that potential went instead into carving a new groove – one which only someone else can fill.

          So I agree with your logic about Juniper to some extent, I differ on the topic of how well known the Story has to be. The public at large doesn’t have to know anything at all about the Story. Like many other things, that can help, but it’s not a requirement. The groove in Creation, and the Role, are the only hard and fast requirements.

          Like

          • The Story doesn’t need to be widely known, it needs to widely resonate. If-people-knew is the criterion. We’re working with a hypothetical omniscient narrator, here.

            It doesn’t have to be known to anyone at all that an Assassin exists and scattered mysterious deaths have a common cause. It just needs to be a fact that IF people knew, they would talk about it. That they would make up a story like this even if it wasn’t true at all. There needs to be resonance, an idea people care about.

            Actual knowledge is not a part of the equation.

            Juniper’s situation is the opposite: even if you told her story to everyone in Callow, most everyone’s eyes would just glaze over and they’d forget most of it instantly.

            Like

  2. Watch next chapter be “land” as in land the shot.
    Also what happened in the Rebel Legion camp plays into Akua’s story. aka Malicia has zero problems with killing even those loyal for short term benefits.

    Liked by 8 people

    • “See? You see? She had the only one among the rebel leadership killed, all so she could make Cat look bad. That’s what his life was worth to her when he wasn’t useful enough to her!”

      Liked by 9 people

    • I wouldn’t exactly call them short term benefits. Right now, Malicia has a very delicate game to play. She needs to wall up the Black Queen and her entire army somewhere, long enough that she can force Cat to the negotiation table, where Malicia actually has a chance of coming out of this with her head attached to her shoulders.

      Any other objectives are secondary to “ensure Malicia’s survival,” and if Cat manages to get out of this trap and spank her army in the process, then Malicia has zero leverage and Cat will just continue rampaging across Praes until everyone in the nation turns against Malicia.

      And we’ve seen what happens to Praesi “lords” when their families decide they’ve had enough.

      On the other hand, if Malicia took all the gloves off, rummaged through the Tower’s basement for all the ancient death rays and doomsday devices, and simply destroyed Cat and her army…well then Procer and Callow either collapse entirely and the Dead King eats the continent …or Cordy uses *her* doomsday device which…basically no-one has any idea what it will do.

      This will also cause Malicia to die, just longer term.

      So. Malicia has to be very careful here or she’ll lose the only thing she has that she actually cares about: her own life.

      Liked by 8 people

      • The thing is, in spite of Juniper’s brilliance, Cat’s power, and the amazing institution of the Callowan army, I’d actually bet good odds on Malicia successfully walking that line. Not great odds, but good odds.

        At least I would if it wasn’t for the fact that Amadeus is waiting in the wings with a mountain’s worth of goblinfire and one Ranger.

        Liked by 7 people

          • Eh, say what you will about Ranger against people, from ordinary soldiers to Named, she’s never shown the propensity for mass property damage that a mountain of goblinfire represents. Catherine’s the one everyone expects to leave a trail of widespread devastation everywhere she goes. Ranger just murder the crap out of everyone unlucky or foolish enough to cross her in any way.

            Like

  3. Malicia’s ploy might get the Rebel Legions aligned against Catherine for now, but at the expense of undermining their leadership (unless Sacker manages to maintain tactical control while making concessions to other elements in the army). So that may shift the numbers against Catherine, but it also makes the force easier to outplay in the field.

    Liked by 6 people

  4. Yay, Juniper got her head out of her ass!

    This is going to be a very confusing fight, no matter how it breaks down. Four elite forces, each unsure of the loyalty or enmity of the other three. Definitely the kind to be decided with knives the night before, as is being shown.

    Liked by 10 people

  5. A lake dropped on a lake and burning a forest; Cat is in top form here.

    I really like Juniper carving into the tree. I hope she survives this to write the definitive text on the art of war.

    Liked by 17 people

    • Also: something something the importance of restraint.

      The difference betweeen Cat’s actual plan and what Malicia framed her for is the number of the bodies on the floor. Killing just Mok vs killing him AND the neutral one.

      Liked by 7 people

    • Eh, more like she saw it was possible for marshal’s to make mistakes since she was seeing something they didn’t seem to, combined with Cat’s anecdote about her own lowest moment of failure.

      Liked by 11 people

    • I think it was realizing that Sacker missed it and was the one the Marshals had predestined to the rank that turned it around. If it was just losing to Grem or Nim that can all come down to her complaint of coming up too fast and not having the experience, but that excuse doesn’t work anymore when she sees Sacker doesn’t see what is going on and Sacker does have the experience. The General she modeled herself on, the one she looked up to and they don’t see it. Also this is almost in a way a reprise of the final at the academy: A four way fight, winner take all.

      Liked by 7 people

    • Is not just that, she was defeated wether by 1 2 or 3 is irrelevant, not even by who, she just realized the important part is what she does with that defeat. Cat literally spelled it out for her but i think she had already come up with the idea when seeing the “box”

      Liked by 1 person

      • I don’t think Juniper figured out the philosophical implications. She did manage to get over herself enough to actually pay attention to the battlefield and NOTICE the box though, so GOOD JOB

        Like

  6. “Trouble,” she said. “I have a fresh word from the Jacks. General Mok was killed an hour ago.”

    I glanced at Scribe, and she nodded. Wow, the Webweaver worked fast.

    *Meanwhile in the rebel camp*: Alright people, so I think it’s safe to say that if we caught the Jacks, that means it’s definitely not Callowans behind this, right? I mean, this is Praes, we know better.
    *Everyone else*: *Nods all around.* Yeah, we’re not stupid, dude. She has Named who could’ve done this more effectively, and there’s two Dread Empresses who’d try something exactly like this.

    Liked by 15 people

    • It *is* pretty funny that they seem to be lapping up the obvious conclusion here given that we’ve seen sayings about how having only a couple layers of deception is a sign of a rank amateur among the highborn lol.

      Liked by 11 people

      • Keep in mind though that most of the Legions isn’t highborn, it’s primarily greenskins, farmers, criminals, etc. with some lesser nobles (like Aisha and Ratface) sprinkled in.

        I’d expect some general cultural competency re: deception in a land that considers Traitorous a national treasure, but the rank and file aren’t generally the ones playing 5D chess — if your family could afford to teach you, you probably had better options than enlisting — so seeded rumors backed by a trusted senior officer will still go a long way.

        Liked by 7 people

      • Keep in mind only highborn do the whole Tzeentch-level plots thing. Normal Praesi citizen like those who serve in the Legions aren’t all that versed in intrigue iirc.

        Liked by 2 people

    • That’ll be officers, and Cat herself says that if she’d had a week to sort this out it would be possible to do so. But the battle is tomorrow and the rank and file will NOT understand the intricacies of “how easily they got caught”.

      Also, nobody knows Cat has Assassin, yet.

      Liked by 1 person

  7. Just imagine the look of their faces when they read that tree and find that all was planned. nice.
    as side note: is the Barrow sword dead? or just irrelevant? he just doesnt appear.

    Liked by 5 people

    • The Barrow Sword is a politician, a would be noble, an amazing fighter, and an excellent warband leader. But of the many things he is, he is not a strategist or a tactician. His intellectual military contributions probably cap out at well-planned raids by a few dozen people, and his political leanings are more towards ingratiating himself with the right people and reading the winds than in decoding military motives and capacity.

      He’s just not useful at this stage of the game. It wouldn’t surprise me if we see him make an appearance in the battle itself though, and/or in the aftermath.

      Liked by 4 people

  8. Damn, I loved Juniper’s development through this arc. Masterfully crafted.

    Can’t wait till the battle. I’m expecting Sepulchral’s army will be a bit of a non factor given it’s probably deeply compromised to Malicia and mostly formed out of levies.

    If it really takes place at dawn, what are the chances Vivienne’s plan, plus the rising sun bears fruit to her Name? Especially if the Callowan deserters desert back – that should have a lot of weight to it. I think another possibility would be Malicia releasing a demon or two to fuck up everyone and Vivi charging against it.

    Liked by 7 people

  9. And so we arrive at the point in the arc where the young pup, distraught at how unskilled her lack of relative experience makes her look, realizes that her young eyes can see better than the old dogs, and that she can more easily pick up new tricks that don’t occur to them. And upon this realization, the gifted child turned brilliant adult makes full use of her faculties and carries the day, appearing as a last hope in the darkest of the night.

    For all she managed to accomplish on her own, in terms of the realizations of her own worth and such, we of course can’t discount her Warlord, who managed to be exactly what she needed at the time, giving her that last bit of steadiness as she Releases the arrow. “How did you do it?” “By doing exactly what you’re planning on doing right now.” As an aside, Cat and the Bard both seemed to have an onscreen “You’re not going to let me die? Okay, I’ll make it everyone else’s problem then” moment before getting up and rocking the world.

    Liked by 8 people

  10. I feel like this will ends up biting Malicia in the back.

    That honest warning Akua gave to Black Knight about how Malicia only see the Legions as her tools? Yeah, this is a pretty grim reminder of that.

    She sacrificed two generals, one in favor of her rule and one neutral, all because she see this move as something that tip the board in her favor, and not even to win the game at that.

    Liked by 10 people

    • Yeah. Honestly, that Nim and Mok didn’t see it coming (I don’t mean now but EVENTUALLY) kind of boggles the mind.

      “Yeah, she mind-controlled everyone to ensure loyalty, but considering nothing has changed and that every new Named she gathers will be even less loyal long-term than the old ones, I’m sure she won’t do it again, right? I mean, that’d be silly.”

      I mean, hindsight 20/20 and all that, but Jesus, Mok…

      Liked by 5 people

      • I think the thing is that for Nim and Mok, failing to reestablish the Legions in their Amadeus-established institutional role is the failure state. They’re not here with the goal of winning battles or conquering territory or elevating rulers. They’re here to reinstate the old system of the Legions that Malicia shattered. Their ability to wage war is simply the mechanism by which they intend to exert leverage, not a goal unto itself. They don’t want war, they want to use their ability to wage war to force Malicia to recognize their importance and make concessions.

        Choosing to betray Malicia, however deservedly, however sensibly, is a failure state. It ends the war, sure, but in a way counter to their stated victory conditions. Which means they were stuck in a godawful situation where the only path with a *chance* of victory involves hoping Malicia doesn’t do exactly this.

        Liked by 8 people

        • Yeah, Nim was fairly upfront about this – if the Legions crown an Empress, then they lose their reputation as an apolitical tool of the Tower and instead become another faction the Tower has to keep happy.

          (For an empire ruled by backstabbing tyrants, Praes has some surprisingly modern ideas about civilian control of the military.)

          Liked by 5 people

          • More like the Legions as a institution are very new (previously they were mook canon-fodder). So there is no precedent for how the modern Legions interact in with the succession of Dread Empress.

            Amadeus seemed to set a slight precedent that the Legions were loyal to the Empress, and where not involved in the factional fighting. But I think the main issue is that the leadership of the modern Legions know how they used to be treated as cannon fodder and never ever want to go back to that. If they become a faction in the succession wars, then if they ever lose one of those succession wars the resulting Dread Emperor might decide to eliminate the modern Legions and reduce them to cannon fodder again.

            But if they become an institution loyal to whoever is the Emperor, well, then their increased competence compared to the old Legions means the Reforms will stick and become unchallenged.

            Liked by 3 people

            • Yes, but the argument only holds water in a vacuum.
              If Malicia wins the succession war, she won’t let the Legions alone because just because they stood loyal this time it’s no guarantee they’ll stay loyal the next time. What if the Black Knight becomes a claimant rather than a High Noble, next time? Who will the Legions follow? She can’t take the risk, she will NEVER take the risk, so EITHER the mind hooks will come again or she’ll dismantle the Legions so they can’t affect the power balance too much. Probably the first one, because Malicia doesn’t ruin something she can suborn instead.
              There is simply no way that the Legions staying put or returning to the fold will result in them becoming an impartial institution under this Empress.

              Liked by 3 people

  11. Yes, Juniper is back. And dumping Arcadian water into a lake already inhabited by giant squid… what impact on the ecosystem will that have?

    Liked by 4 people

    • I’m guessing the usual Praesi thing that happens when you dump an unholy amount of toxic magic into the ecosystem. More terrifying abominations to make coming generations rue the people who came before them, especially whichever asshole is responsible for the glamour-using near-invisible krakens in the lake.

      Liked by 10 people

  12. Typo Thread:

    look at. The > look at that. The
    afford game > afford a game
    like withered > like a withered
    founding > finding
    it’s been obvious to be > it’d been obvious to me
    gesture vaguely > gestured vaguely
    so the Carrion > so did the Carrion
    blinders went off > blinders came off
    it the air > it in the air
    I’d pretty > It’d pretty
    least of tone > least a tonne
    so, at least, (should probably be “at last”)
    to make suborning (should this be stop)
    not telling > no telling
    “Have assassin > “Have Assassin

    Liked by 1 person

  13. [“Call me girl again and I’ll make you eat your own tongue,” I calmly told her.]

    I remember when Duchess of Moonless Nights made that fey eat their own fingers, and when Catherine was really horrified at the depths to which she’d descended. Feels like we’re getting back around to the auto-canibalism train.

    Liked by 3 people

    • Malicia framed them for doing the thing they were going to frame Sepurchal for.

      Cat really needs to get quicker at this though she really is her mother’s daughter in that sense. Or learn to assume any clever plan she can come up with is already in motion against her.

      Liked by 1 person

    • They weren’t going to kill Seket, and the difference is pretty big: a surgical strike on just the specific guy who is a diehard for opposing them vs leaving only the person who advocated joining them.

      Liked by 1 person

  14. Glad we confirmed that Arcadian water is indeed incompatible with at least some Creational creatures physiology, even though Arcadia mimics Creation. Though that may be due to how close Arcadia is to Creation rather than anything else(grooves just go through and imprint on Arcadia perhaps). Their matter at its base differs in inbuilt rules compared to those of Creation and presumably even if Arcadia is similar its kind of like a being levo-amino acid based vs dextro amino acid based. It also seems that, similar to munitions or alchemy, Arcadian water can subsume or at least partially change other matter its exposed to? Quite curious about what kind of rituals or perhaps mastery if one has the mantle of a Court, could be used to make its constituents similar enough to be survivable. Being claimed/swearing fealty to a court also seems a potential route for achieving this. Given how similar this seems to devils and presumably demons being inedible, I wonder if there are similar acts one could do to become compatible with them.

    Juniper appeared to have a kind of hopeful, “broken pedestal” moment. She saw that those she looked up to werent invincible, kind of a “glass half-full” moment since now there are possibilities beyond defeat to her internal review of their capabilities.

    Liked by 2 people

    • I mean, I think it’s less that the Arcadian water changes the normal matter so much as the water gets mixed together so that even if your glass is 3/4 normal water there’s enough Arcadian Atoms to make you sick. It’s likely Akua could come up with a spell to banish the arcadian water out of barrels of water to leave it normal, but doing it enough to supply an entire army would probably burn out every mage they have.

      Liked by 3 people

      • The thing is the trick would be easy, if time intensive, if its just something like contamination. Assuming the density differs(given it is from presumably the area around where Winter was) you would just need to wait for the water to level out into different areas of density, probably helped by using those magical panes to help push water down, or just excite it by heating it up

        Like

      • The way it works is quite simple. Water is just water. But lake water isn’t just water. Lake water also contains oils and organisms and minerals and things. In the teal world, those oils and organisms and some of the things are all left- handed in their very make up, all the way down to the smallest bits that can be described that way. But in Arcadia, these same oils and organisms and things are right-handed.

        This is fine as long as both realms are separate. Right-handed things interact with other right handed things in the same ways that left-handed things interact with other left handed things. But put a right handed amino acid in a left handed organism and it makes its way where it would normally go if the handedness matched, until it reaches another left handed thing. Then, the right handed akino acid and left handed thing interact completely differently from how they should. Maybe they don’t at all, or maybe they interact when they’d normally just pass by each other.

        Now, add enough right handed things to a left handed body, and all kinds of biological processes start to go wrong within the body. Pretty much as if the body had been poisoned.

        Despite what this sounds like this isn’t even nonsense. It’s Chirality.

        https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chirality_(chemistry)

        Liked by 4 people

    • I’m likewise glad to see it confirmed that Arcadian water is unsafe, but I think the chirality argument is on a hiding to nothing… remember, this is a much more magical universe, with its chemistry explicitly off-limits due to the gnomes.

      Miles’ point about “organisms” is closer, especially since it’s been made clear that in Arcadia, there’s much less distinction between the “things” and the “people”. Arcadian water isn’t just H2O that happens to come from someplace else, it’s the material of a realm that predates the mortal entirely, charged with powers and essences that really don’t belong in the mortal world. Never mind bacteria, worry about undines, especially given there were monsters present already!

      So yeah, the Wasteland has now gotten even more weird and hostile… Maybe the lake will eventually come up with its own corrupted-fae Ladies to hand out baleful daggers.

      Liked by 2 people

  15. I just can’t get past the idea of Drunk Akua watching Catherine pull that same goddamn trick /again/.

    “– I beg your pardon?”
    “Lakeomancy. That’s what she calls it.”
    “That’s… that’s not what you’d call that.”
    “Feel free to tell her that.”
    “How can we stop it?”
    “I dunno, steal the /rest/ of the lakes in Arcadia first? But we haven’t cut a deal with the elves like she did, so we’ll get swarmed by Spring or October or whatever fresh catastrophe she’s unleashed in the twenty minutes since nobody’s been looking over Hierophant’s shoulder.”

    Liked by 6 people

  16. Everyone who is or could be a Marshal of Praes.”

    For a second this made me wonder whether this while battle will decide who gets the Name of Marshal. But the mention of Creation not reacting makes me doubt that.

    Like

    • I think Marshal doesn’t get to be a Name (as Grem demonstrated by not getting it). It would be because most people on Calernia really just don’t care about that role enough for it to be a Role. Oh some guys in a tent at the back of the camp argued and one of them had a personal crisis? How very fascinating. Can you tell me about the wolf cavalry charging against the knights though?

      Like

  17. I mean Juniper could win this and become the one true Marshall but even if she has a great plan. How much of the win will be because of that great plan and not the fact that her side has what half a dozen Named and few people on the cusp of getting Names. Nim has herself and Akua working on it…the rest have zero.
    Granted I am happy Juniper will get a chance to shine and not be such a sad sack. Just that while painting the Grand Alliance here as a major underdog, EE seems seriously downplaying their obvious advantage in Named, as to be honest the troop differences aren’t that major. Assuming no one teams up.

    Liked by 1 person

  18. I started reading PGTE about a month ago. Today is the day I caught up. I expect I shall have a lot more free time in the coming days.

    Like

Leave a comment