“It is fortunate that virtue is its own reward, as it does not tend to accrue others.”
– Theodore Langman, Wizard of the West
The world had become as an oil painting and the Night was boiling in my veins.
Goddesses on dark wings claimed my shoulders, insolent shards of darkness refusing the ascendancy of the afternoon sun, and they said nothing. They didn’t need to. The expectation bloomed in the back of my mind like a swelling river: I’d offered them faith before they ever named me priestess, but now they required that purpose of me. Night still ran deep in the veins of the drow, however changed its nature, but none of their ancient favourites had been granted my office. First Under the Night, I thought. To others it might speak of supremacy, some perilous boast of standing closer to these quarrelsome goddesses than any other, but I knew better. I was first in that I was charged with the treading of unbroken grounds, as much a scream ringing into a dark tunnel as a priestess bearing their mandate. I was to stumble for them, make the mistakes and pay the costs so that my successors would not. These were still fair terms, by my reckoning. Alliance and the means to carry out my designs, for what I had freely given before they formally claimed it. But if they expected reverence of me, respect more than had been earned, then they would be disappointed.
“I never took well to prayer,” I murmured. “Either the secret whispers for help or the worn-down words they taught us to recite in the House. So I won’t offer you that.”
The sun above was searing, blinding. Fire from above none of us were meant to look in the eye. I breathed out and let the wind thread its fingers through my hair. The power came easy to me. It was holding it that was the trouble, for it was as temperamental as its mistresses: I’d ruled Winter, by the scavenger’s virtue of being last to hold sway over it, but the Night was not my domain. If I wanted the crows to smile upon me, I would have to swing them as sweet a song as I had it in me to sing.
“But that’s not what we’re about, is it?” I said. “The three of us. If you wanted someone who’d know your pretty rituals, you had thousands to raise. If you wanted devotion, or unquestioning faith, there just as plenty. You went through my mind mercilessly, that night, so you know exactly what you picked.”
My eyes left the sky and fell to the charging Levantines. Thousands in mail and leather and scales, steel blades and hide shields. Their faces painted with vivid strokes of colour, as true a language as the spoken tongues of their faraway land. They were close now, treading river grounds. I had chosen the broadest bent of the water for this, instead of where my armies had once tried to shatter winter’s work with the cleverness of the Grey Eyries. I raised my staff and let the darkness pulse with me.
“Here’s my prayer, Goddesses of Night,” I savagely smiled. “The three of us, together – let’s break something.”
Komena’s raucous, delighted laughter sounded in my ears even as the bottom of my staff struck the snow-covered ice. The oldest sister might see further, weave and scheme with cold judgement, but the younger one was my kindred in some ways. Even the span of millennia had not entirely faded the remembrance of what it felt like, shattering arrogance and host with the same single stroke. The soldier-goddess leaned into my intent more strongly than her sister, harsh and domineering where Andronike was skillful and subtle. The Night spread with a whisper before sinking its claws in the iced river, rending it mercilessly. Cracks tore open the frozen grounds, cold water sloshed out and hundreds of screams filled the air. Komena roughly withdrew her will from mine, leaving me gasping and leaning on my staff for reasons deeper than a bad leg. My sight swam, the glare of the sun failing to pierce through, and I had just enough presence left to hear Robber hesitantly stepping towards me. I warded him off with a raised hand. Gods, I thought. I felt like throwing up, like my veins were about to boil and melt. I’d never wielded a miracle this large during the light of day, and I wouldn’t do it again anytime soon if I had my way.
“Boss?” Robber called out.
“Took a bit out of me, that’s all,” I croaked out.
Too many breaths passed before I was myself again, but with eyes no longer rebelling I steadied my back spat to the side. The river had become a deep grave, I saw. There were chunks of ice floating in the water, but among them bodies were strewn. Fewer than had died, though that was no mystery: those with weightier armour had sunk straight to the bottom. The floaters had been savaged by broken ice. Some Levantines were still swimming and screaming, but I had little worry of survival. Taking a swim this deep into winter was as sure as death sentence as a swinging sword, unless some priest intervened. My last memories of the charge were vague, almost dreamlike – there were consequences, to calling upon that much Night and the aid of a goddess – but now I could more accurately assess numbers. Around two thousand had sallied out towards my little company, and less than half that died. Their mistake had been going into battle order, I mused. That’d broadened their line, turning the loss of a few hundred into something closer to a thousand. There were still a mass of soldiers mobilizing behind the survivors of the ill-fated assault, almost the full Levantine reserve, but I had no fear of that. They were on the wrong side of the river, after all.
The cavalry in the distance that had been heading for us earlier has slowed, and there seemed to be argument between its officers. They were on our bank, sure, but then they’d just watched me turn around a mile of ice into a deathtrap. And there’d be no reinforcements, if they tried their luck. I suspected they would be disinclined to find out if I had anymore tricks up my sleeves, which was for the best. I might actually fall unconscious, if I attempted to use the Night again, and not necessarily after I’d let loose a miracle. I wouldn’t risk it, not when anything capable of hurting the horsemen would be just as capable of ravaging my own soldiers if lashing out uncontrollably.
“That one wants your head on a pike,” Robber said, calling my attention back to the footsoldiers.
Or close enough. On the other bank, a rider stood surrounded by panicking captains. A young man, in beautiful plate that must have cost a fortune. He couldn’t even be twenty, I thought, though the ferocious-looking facepaint of iron grey and crimson made it hard to determine. He was looking at me with hatred and fear. The enemy’s commander?
“Might be able to end him with a volley,” my Special Tribune offered. “Best not to let snakes grow longer fangs.”
“So young,” I quietly said.
“You were younger, when you took your first command,” Robber shrugged.
Seventeen, and so sure I was ready to mend my little corner of the world. Gods, how lucky had I been to have the likes of Juniper and Hakram at my side? All of Rat Company, really, and those others handpicked by then then-legate Hellhound as well. But it wasn’t luck at all, was it? I suddenly thought. Heroes might have providence to furnish them with the tools of victory, but I’d had something of my own just as valuable. A patient man with green eyes, lending his weight where mine did not suffice and pulling a thousand strings to ease my way forward – so many of them I could not believe I’d found half, even after all these years.
“We learned our lessons quick,” I said. “We had to.”
Not always the right ones, I knew, but we had learned. We still did. The moment you stopped, Creation buried you.
“He’ll remember today, Boss,” Robber said. “You can count on that. And next time he comes swinging, he’ll be wiser about it.”
The warning was clear. It ran against goblin nature, to let a threat escape. And there’d been promise in this one, if he’d really been in command. Going for the general staff was a tactic that would have worked against almost any army on Calernia. He’d run into Grem One-Eye and Black’s reforms instead, the forced redundancies shaped by the knowledge that you couldn’t count on high command surviving a battle if heroes were on the loose, but the Dominion had never fought the modern Legions of Terror so the mistake was understandable. Pressing the offensive, as he’d obviously meant to, had not been unsound either. It would have been costly, but if General Abigail’s defences broken on even one front her army would have collapsed in short order. If he’d been slightly luckier, if I’d arrived a day later, he might very well have broken the Third Army completely. If you’d had maybe another ten years of seasoning, I thought. If you’d been trained better, learned to temper the bold with some patience… He could be a general of some talent, one day. No Juniper, mind you, but thankfully there were very few generals of that skill around. And if I gave him those ten years, one day the hate I saw might be turned on me with a wiser hand to wield it.
“Let him go,” I said.
Yellow eyes considered me carefully.
“This isn’t a victory, Robber,” I sighed, gesturing at the river full of dead. “It’s a waste.”
“Not like you to weep for the enemy,” the goblin said.
“Weep?” I mused. “No, hardly that. But every corpse we make today is a gap in the ranks when we turn to the Dead King.”
I sighed, then glanced aside. In the distance, I saw the cavalry had decided to ride around the river and return to the camp. Good.
“Come on,” I said. “Time to head back. General Abigail should be wrapping up inside the city.”
I began limping back to Sarcella, leaving ice and death behind. The hateful stare of the boy I’d spared followed my back, but what of it?
He wouldn’t be the first, or the last.
—
With the enemy riders away, there was no need to risk anything as foolish as trying the blaze a second time. Most the turtles were wrecked beyond use, anyway, and while Belles Portes had been under assault when we moved out I judged my forces too weak for a strike at the back of the Levantines still holding it. We took the long way around, the threat of the horsemen having removed itself, and long was no exaggeration. Though my drow tread snow like stone and goblins could scuttle through anything, I was exhausted beyond words and very much limping. It turned out that victory outpaced us: when we reached the eastern side of Sarcella, we were greeted by rowdy cheers. Word of the river’s break had spread faster than I could walk, and more besides. The cohort positioned to hold the eastern streets crowded us to deliver accolades, or at least tried to – I sent Robber ahead to have a quiet word with the captain about not approaching the drow. They looked a little stunned by the welcome, nonetheless, almost like children seeing the sea for the first time. The Everdark did not breed the kind of comradeship that the Legions and my armies used as mortar. Mighty Jindrich was strutting like a peacock and its sigil followed suit, which amused my legionaries to no end.
I left them to it, and took aside the orc captain in command of the cohort. The news were better than I had expected. General Abigail, it seemed, had vigorously prosecuted her offensive and then taken a gamble as well. She’d recalled the two thousand drow I’d left holding the north of the city and sent them to climb the ring of statues and arches around the city, to suddenly drop down at the back of the Levantines in Belles Portes. That’d neatly cut off both the bridges that still allowed a trickle of Dominion reinforcements to come through and the last way out of the force inside Sarcella. The enemy commander, facing annihilation, had been forced to surrender. I suspected the casualty rate for the drow who’d taken the climb and been forced to fight Levantines on both sides was a lot less sunny than the official version implied, but regardless I did not disapprove. Simply by ending the fighting early, General Abigail had likely significantly lowered overall casualties. The wary-eyed Callowan I’d promoted to the head of the Third Army had accepted the surrender as soon as it was offered, and Sarcella was now entirely ours. For now, anyway. There were still Dominion soldiers beyond the bridges, and the losses we’d taken during the offensive must not have been mild.
But it was only a few hours until sundown, now, so I had no fear of what was ahead.
After we advanced deeper into the city I sent Mighty Jindrich and its warriors back to the rest of the drow with a message to General Rumena, ordering it to pull back to the now-unguarded north of the city and away from the rest of the Third Army. It’d cover our bases, just in case, but that was only a side benefit. The longer my army and the Firstborn remained in close quarters, the higher the chances of blood being spilled rose – especially if I wasn’t there to supervise. The survivors of Robber’s cohort I relieved with my compliments, free to sleep or whatever no-doubt-against-regulations activity they got up to when they weren’t on duty. Robber himself wanted to stay at my side, but I had something else in mind and so refused.
“You keeping me away from the Dominion prisoners, Boss?” he pouted.
It was even odds, I mused whether or not he knew that make him look like a particularly horrid gargoyle. The amusement the sight caused was slight, though, and did not linger long. It wasn’t amusing at all, what I needed of him.
“No,” I softly said. “I need you to find out what happened to Nauk’s body. If they’ve burned it yet, if they had time for a Legion burial.”
The pout vanished, leaving behind a grim visage of wrinkled green skin. They’d had a complicated relationship, those two: adversarial and often petty, tainted by their largely one-sided competition for Pickler’s attentions, but there’d also been more to it than that. It’s been a comfortable kind of dislike, the kind so old and well-worn it had some kinship to friendship. And beyond that, Nauk had been Rat Company. He’d been with us from the start, the War College and those heady first days of the Fifteenth. That mattered, to those who’d been there. There weren’t as many of us left as I’d like.
“I’ll see to it,” Robber said, and for once his voice was completely serious.
“Please,” I said. “If the body’s still there…”
“I’ll arrange something, and send for you,” the goblin said.
It wasn’t a sweet parting, but this wasn’t sweet business. I ran into officers sent by General Abigail on my way to the Third Army’s headquarters, and learned the surrendered Levantine captains were being kept in the repurpose goal of Sarcella closer to the north, under heavy guard. The Dominion soldiers themselves had been disarmed, and while under watch had been provided healing by priests of the House Insurgent. I made my way to the headquarters as quick as I could, my leg was aching like someone had shoved an iron spike through. It was an effort not to visibly tremble from exhaustion, now that the miracle’s wake had fully settled over my shoulders, but I couldn’t show weakness in front of my soldiers. At least my shoulders were bare, now. The crows had left when I began the trek back to Sarcella earlier, presumably to look for fresh amusements. In this city full of corpses and ash I had no doubt they’d find something to their tastes. The merchant’s mansion that served as the location of the Third Army’s high command was a great deal fuller than the last time I’d swung by. It was surrounded by legionaries, and even inside soldiers were aplenty. The mood was celebratory, but while I offered smiles I did not linger. I was too tired to keep up the pretence of haleness for long, and I still had duties to discharge.
I made my way up to the war council room, finding what remained of Nauk’s general staff there and surrounding his successor. The general was the first to notice my arrival, rising up her seat looking like she would very much love to be halfway through a good night’s sleep right now. I could sympathize.
“Your Majesty,” she greeted me.
Huh, she’d done the salute perfectly even this exhausted. Whoever had drilled her at the recruitment camp must have left quite the impression.
“General,” I replied. “And all of you – you should be proud of what you’ve accomplished today. You went above and beyond my expectations.”
I was unsurprised to notice it was the orcs who were most pleased by that, demurely flashing fangs in a signal of humility.
“There will be another war council later, but for now I’ll need the room,” I calmly said. “I must speak with your general.”
Being sent out didn’t seem to dent their good mood all that much, and I smiled to take the sting out anyway. It wasn’t long before we had the room to ourselves, though I waited until footsteps could no longer be heard. General Abigail, I noted, seemed to be willing to look anywhere in the room except at me. I wondered whether she was always jumpy as a cat, or whether it was the result of days of march under harassment followed by battles and a spectacular assassination of her direct colleagues. She was a cagey one, this Abigail of Summerholm. Her eyes never quite stopped moving, as if always looking for a threat, and I’d yet to see her let her guard down entirely once even this far behind our defence lines. I would have thought her generally inclined to prudence, but the way she’d used the drow in the battle ran against that impression.
I’d been solid thinking, if risky, and raised my opinion of her as a tactician. It would have been safer to stick to a steady push, but overall casualties would have been higher by the time the dust settled. Add that to the clever trick she’d pulled using civilians to guard the back of Sarcella, and I had to admit she was one of the more promising commanders who’d risen over the last few years. Not yet enough to remain a general, maybe, but she had the potential to get there after a bit of blooding. Which Juniper had assigned her under Nauk to get, I remembered with a touch of rue. It seemed the Hellhound and I were sharing an opinion without needing to share a room. I dragged myself to one of the seats at the table and plopped myself down, brutally suppressing a sigh, and invited her to do the same. She did after the barest of hesitations.
“You did well today,” I said. “The river trick would have meant nothing if you hadn’t pushed them out beforehand.”
The black-haired woman forced a smile and a nod while muttering her thanks. I didn’t begrudge her that in the slightest. She’d sent quite a few of her soldiers to die, today, legionaries and officers she likely knew quite well. It never quite felt like a victory, when the butcher’s bill came in, did it?
“You’ll be remaining in command of the Third Army until we join up with the other columns,” I told her. “Possibly until we make contact with Marshal Juniper, if there’s no suitable replacement for you.”
She winced.
“Ma’am, I’m not sure that’s a wise decision,” Abigail said. “I went up the ranks fast, and I didn’t go through the War College. All I got was the officer training in the camps, and it didn’t cover a general’s duties.”
My lips quirked.
“If a few years at the College were enough to make a general, my life would be much easier,” I said. “I’ll be handling the drow, and a few other forms of trouble as well. I can’t run the Third Army as well. You’ve acquitted yourself well, and you have the instincts for it. It’ll have to do.”
Her face fell, and once more I was struck with how young she was. I wasn’t all that older, truth be told, but it’d been a long time since I’d felt my true age. Gods, were we ever really that young? We must have been, when we fought in the Liesse Rebellion. I wondered if we’d looked as fragile to old generals like Istrid and Sacker back then as Abigail now looked to me.
“A lot of people could die, if I make a mistake,” she muttered. “That would be on my head.”
Doubt, I thought. She wasn’t so difficult to read that I could not pick up on it. And resentment at being thrust into this role. Both things could turn out dangerous, if allowed to fester. A lighter touch would be needed here, or maybe a personal one. There were times when twisting the arm was in order, but not here. An entirely unwilling general was of no use to me, and likely a liability to the soldiers she’d be commanding. Doubt and resentment, huh. I was no stranger to either, and in my experience they tended to have a common source in fear. We’d begin there. Propping up my staff against the table, I leaned back into my seat.
“In my first serious fight, I was beaten within an inch of my life by a procession of strangers and afterwards eviscerated by the Lone Swordsman,” I told her quietly. “I still have the scar from where he opened me up. I was close enough to death I managed to use necromancy to get myself moving.”
The other woman’s eyes widened, with both surprise and disgust. The latter was at necromancy – most of my countrymen still considered the practice disgusting and dangerous – but the former was not. It wasn’t common knowledge, how badly William had trounced me during the first part of our encounter. I watched curiosity seep in after the words sunk in, so I pressed on while the iron was hot.
“I ended up kicking him off the ramparts and into the Hwaerte, after catching him by surprise,” I said, “but it was a very, very close thing. There are some who’d call it fate, the way it all turned out. I tend to think of it as luck.”
“You were Named, even then,” General Abigail said.
Like that said it all, explained everything. I supposed it might, to someone who’d never slipped into a Role. It was a lot more eye-catching the way some of us scythed through soldiers like wheat stalks than the way a single story misstep might kill you in truth an entire year before the blade actually opened your throat.
“I was green,” I corrected. “Scrappy, good at some parts of what I did, but dangerously arrogant in my approach and I nearly died choking on a floor for it. But it did teach me a valuable lesson.”
I smiled mirthlessly.
“You’ll get eviscerated too, Abigail,” I said, and she didn’t quite manage to hide her flinch. “Not literally as I was, but one day you’ll make a mistake and it’ll be costly. You can’t avoid that day, no one can. And it’s good that you’re afraid of it.”
I met her eyes, brown to blue.
“Take that fear and use it,” I said. “To make yourself think. About how it could go wrong, what you could do to avoid it or survive it. And from there you plan so that you don’t end up in that pit in the first place. You do that well enough, and you’ll push back the day some.”
I paused, just a heartbeat.
“It’ll still come,” I frankly said. “It comes for everyone, Abigail. But if you can ward it off for a year or two, you’ll still have done better than half the generals on Calernia.”
A grimace split the other woman’s face.
“I could have been a tanner,” General Abigail mournfully said. “No one ever expects anything from those.”
“I served drinks in a tavern for years,” I told her, reluctantly amused. “And I ended up with a crown on my head. You’re getting off light.”
She paled, which made her sun-tanned cheeks look rather blotchy, but gathered herself with remarkable alacrity.
“I don’t suppose I am dismissed for rest, now,” she cautiously ventured.
I snorted.
“There’s no rest for the wicked, General Abigail,” I said. “Find us a bottle of wine and come back. We’ll be going over the orders you’ve given since you took command of the Third Army, and why you gave them.”
The black-haired woman let out a sound that might have been a whimper. I raised an eyebrow and she rose to find us something to drink, while I let out a sigh at the relief that was no longer standing on my bad leg.
Much like her I’d rather be sleeping, but if she was to be the first Callowan general in my army then she needed to be taught.
Go vote!
http://topwebfiction.com/vote.php?for=a-practical-guide-to-evil
LikeLiked by 6 people
Maybe?
I prefer to read the story.
LikeLike
This bodes well for those desiring more of Abigail.
She’ll either go far, or go out in a blaze of (reluctant) glory.
Holy crap – Abigail is the Callowan Caiphas Cain!!
Ehhhh … killing him is kind of a wash. He’s probably not going to be in command much longer, but the lessons he learns from getting his ass kicked this way might prove to be useful against the Dead King. And that would likely be worth leaving him alive, especially since killing him isn’t certain.
LikeLiked by 12 people
Because of how Fate works, I wouldnt be surprised to see him next chapter to discuss a sort of cease fire or something.
Cat really doesnt have the reasons, nor will to fight Humans right now. She needs Black, and everyone is needed on the front with Dead King. For all we know, the Tomb has been broken and the fall of Hannover will shrink the frontline to allow the Dead King to potentially send a “recruitment drive” into the rattlings.
LikeLiked by 14 people
If cat was still named, I’d have been screaming she just killed herself, that’s literally the sort of thing that makes an origin story for the hero that gets you. But, at least for now, she’s not, so it was probably a decent move.
LikeLiked by 4 people
I would choke on laughter if she ends up getting a diplomatic Name out of this shitshow.
All jokes aside, she is practicing realpolitik: Being able to recruit a formerly fallen empire, negotiating with the likes of Dead King, Dwarves, Gods, Good, and Evil. She gives exactly what they deserve and expect, while at the same time furthering the end goals (even if she loses sight of them temporarily.)
LikeLiked by 3 people
Yep!
LikeLike
It’s worth the gamble. Cat may well be tutoring two generals with one throw.
And, as pointed out… potential generals with decent enough instincts don’t grow on trees, and Calernia will need every one of them knocked down a few pegs and built back up for some time in the not-too-distant future.
LikeLiked by 5 people
Eh. He’s only fit to be sword fodder to be marched into the Dead King’s meatgrinder.
LikeLike
Honestly, Abigail reminds me of book 1 Cat more than anything. maybe a bit more hostile to the Call and less mouthy, but she’s still got that same mix of resolve and wondering how the hells she got here.
LikeLiked by 12 people
I see just two issues with these devisions: the first reeks of the Lone Swordsman, who was actually brought up in this chapter. And the second is Cat getting a pupil. As it was often said to Black, that story tends to end with the mentor dead. She must be careful their relationship doesn’t turn into that. Maybe by shagging Abigail, now that she’s into sleeping with people again.
LikeLiked by 3 people
The parallel is more of the way Black handled the aftermath of the Conquest, not the Lone Swordsman. It wasn’t some emotional need for redemption that she let him go. She let him go because it was a ‘waste’, and there’d already been enough of that for one day.
It’s the same reason Amadeus built Callow back up after the conquest, even though it was a murderously rebellious breeding ground for Heroes, and collectively considered him public enemy number one. As dangerous as it was, it was still more useful alive than dead.
The mentor thing is a legitimate threat, but we have to keep in mind the bigger picture here. Cat has never been about personal survival, she’s a mirror to her own mentor in that sense. As much as she’s changed she’s still the same person who thought it was a damn good bargain to trade in her own life for liesse, if it came down to it; and the stakes she’s playing for now are a hell of a lot higher than just one major city. As nice as survival is, it’s likely not actually at the top of her list of end-goals.
LikeLiked by 15 people
^^^ this.
LikeLike
I mean I don’t think mentor getting you killed applies. Cat is not Named currently and Abigail has never had a Name. Not to mention the age difference being what 2-3 years max and the difference in role. Sure Abigail might become Queen of Callow but she is not really in line to succeed Cat as First Under Night. The titles are not connected.
LikeLiked by 4 people
You’ll recall Black still decapitated any rebellious movements and leaders. Letting a general so openly hostile to him live was not Black’s style.
Also, Cat did not let the Lone Swordsman live out of emotion, but calculation.
We can only hope this young man does not have the weight to initiate a pattern of three with her, or get a Name out of the deal.
LikeLike
Black was conquering Callow. Cat’s not conquering Procer, much less Levant. Long-term, she’s looking at an alliance, not a low key simmering war of mutual extermination.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Normally i’d say either was likely but CAT ISN’T NAMED. At least for now. That saves her.
LikeLiked by 1 person
She’s still got enough weight she might as well be. Probably a bit less bound to stories, but bound enough that it matters a lot.
LikeLike
I think Cat is taking the longer view by not killing the “boy”. Yes, she risks him becoming a personal enemy by leaving him alive. However, killing him gives her one less officer when it comes time to fight the Dead King. From here on out, she needs to conserve the lives of not only her troops but her enemy’s troops because she will need every living soul!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Hot dang. Cat is a walking airstrike in a medieval setting. She is too op.
I’m glad Abigail is going to end up relevant. Ben rooting for that since she first appeared. RIP Nauk. But TBH the orc was sort of dead inside already.
LikeLike
Didn’t mean to reply, sorry
LikeLike
I’m sure Cats bad leg remains a secret weapon in her narrative war.
Good writing!
LikeLiked by 6 people
Truely a daughter of Black. His horrifying, well meaning daughter in all the best and worst aspects. She has even inherited his method of dealing with subordinates and mending bridges.
LikeLiked by 21 people
Abigail is luckier than she knows. Cat is one of the better tacticians on Calernia; not Juniper or Grem tier, but just one or two below that. We can probably count the number outright better than her on two hands. Of course, Abigail’s also not lucky; she’ll mess up eventually, and the consequences will be harsh. But hopefully this will help her get through it.
We’re going to see that Levantine officer again, and when we do we’ll find out whether it was a good or bad thing he was let go. I have a suspicion it will be a bad thing. Hatred isn’t healthy to ones’ mindset, and will taint any cooperation in the future.
LikeLiked by 15 people
I see Cat as a good Tactician, but not anywhere near Juniper or Grem tier.
She is great at mind games and unconventional warfare (including heroic and villainous bullshit).
Given equal means and information, I see Juniper trouncing Cat 99/100 times. But that’s not how Cat fights, and both times Cat has beaten Juniper, is because she pulled a new weapon system or unknown variable. Cat looks so good because she can steal the initiative, then has to keep up the tempo to prevent a loss. The probelm she runs into, is rushing into one disaster then another to maintain that initiative.
I think that a cease fire will be called soon, seeing as Callow now holds both the city wall and several thousand hostages, and Cat has been getting better at diplomacy.
LikeLiked by 14 people
Cat only actually beat Juniper once. What she did the other time was in its own way even more impressive: She manipulated the story so the “price” she had to pay for victory was something immensely profitable, namely poaching Juniper for her own faction.
LikeLiked by 10 people
Juniper’s a great tactician, Cat’s a great strategist. If Juniper and Cat were on opposing sides of a war, it wouldn’t look like the five-way melee, it would look like Juniper being never given battle where she wasn’t at a bad enough disadvantage that the best her tactical acumen can do is make the defeat slightly less harsh.
The fact Juniper IS at Cat’s side is a function of Cat’s skill as a strategist.
LikeLiked by 10 people
She’s an A Tier strategist while Juniper and Grem are SS tier. Thankfully, there are very, very few S tier. As few as their are SS tier probably, or even less.
The main difference between Cat and Juniper, to keep the fighting game analogy going, is that Cat is controlled by a player, while Juniper is controlled by a CPU at max level.
LikeLiked by 18 people
The thing about hardest-difficulty AI vs. player is actually a quite good metaphor.
LikeLiked by 4 people
I kind of see Abigail becoming an anti-Named General, her tactics will get her ass kicked by normal armies but will chew up and shit out corpses of Named and other supernatural forces.
LikeLiked by 4 people
But she just got her start as General by doing well against an army with no Named in it…
LikeLiked by 3 people
IDK, so far she’s seemed to me like her best skill is adapting to how regular people think.
The anti-riot wine is characteristic.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Well, she was good enough to plant the seed of impotence into the heart of the Mirror Knight (aka shiny fucker) in Kaleidoscope IV-VI.
Speaking of which, shiny fucker needs to die fast now that there are Drow in the field given that one of his Aspects is [Dawn] which makes him stronger every morning.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m not saying Abigail isn’t going to be good at handling Named, I’m just predicting that she’s not going to be easy meat for mundane generals :3
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oops, not what I was trying to reply to.
WRT this, shiny fucker is on the same side. Catherine’s going to kick everyone’s ass into realizing that this is not a zero-sum game, with as few losses as possible.
LikeLike
That’s the goal, but I don’t think it’s actually possible to achieve without large amounts of bloodshed, and the Named are going to resist the hardest, because they have the highest stakes in the game. So the probability of Cat having a big showdown with the heroes that ends with most of them dead somewhere down the line is actually pretty high.
LikeLiked by 1 person
True!
I root for as many of them surviving as possible though, as does Catherine :3
LikeLike
No, wait, I WAS replying to this. Reading comprehension: 1, me: 0
LikeLiked by 1 person
Being a tactician is just her secondary talent. Setting up the narrative for a story and dealing with Named on the other side is what she is really good at–similar to how Amadeus and Grem are running things IMO.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Indeed.
I consider Catherine a tactician second, however. She’s thirdly a warrior, secondly a tactician, but first and foremost a storyteller.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s worth noting that storyteller => politician ==> strategist ======> tactician ==> warrior.
These things aren’t independent. Each of them requires slightly different skills / knowledge base, but a lot of it flows around interconnectedly. Making things look&sound good is a common skill between storyweaver and politician. Seeing the big picture is a common skill between storyweaver, politician and strategist. Being aware of how other players are motivated and think is a common skill between politician, strategist and tactician. Knowing the actual mechanics&logistics of battles is a common skill between strategist and tactician. Being able to follow the situation as it develops and think quickly&clearly under pressure is a common skill between tactician and warrior. Etc.
And Catherine being good at storyweaving occasionally translates immediately into tactical success. Well, that was mostly against fae, but the point that she knew which skill to lean on too win stands, you know?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Abigail is going to be Queen. She’s pretty much being set up as Catherine’s successor, because this sounds somewhat like the beginning of an apprenticeship. Cat really reminds me of black here in a lot of ways with how she’s thinking about handling her new charge.
LikeLiked by 17 people
It’s going to be her or Thief, I’m pretty sure Viv either lost her name or transitioned, so her becoming the next queen isn’t out of the picture.
LikeLiked by 7 people
“Petty thieves hang, the great wear crowns.”
LikeLiked by 13 people
I find myself wondering… if Viv has lost her Name of Thief, what happens to all the loot she’s stolen and hidden in her Aspect-linked hideaway? Perhaps one of her new Aspects will be “Gift”. 😉
LikeLiked by 2 people
The next Thief acquires it.
Equivalently, the next person to acquire it becomes the next Thief.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Hmm. I don’t recall seeing anything about Viv inheriting a stash of treasure and sundry knick-knacks, so I don’t think so. The stash does look suspiciously like a personal domain, but we don’t really know much about those. The closest thing we’ve seen are Warlock’s and Masiego’s private storage dimensions, but those are explicitly created… and we don’t know what happens to them either. In fact, that might be an issue — what important items might have been stashed in Warlock’s private storage dimension?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh nice, good point.
LikeLike
I just worry about that. As Black was told many times, training a successor is quite a death flag.
LikeLiked by 1 person
So is leaving a young noble alive to plan revenge, something makes me think that cat isn’t planning to survive after the battle against the dead king.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Mayhap. I rather suspect Black squeezed any suicidal tendencies out of her early on the apprenticeship.
LikeLike
I’m worried Black might have infected her with suicidal tendencies, as a matter of fact.
>My own fate was ultimately a side note: if I had to go for Callow to finally stop bleeding, then I’d pull that trigger without hesitation. I’d had a good teacher when it came to the lesson of not getting in your own way.
He’s tried his best to teach her to be kinder to herself than that.
>“Human,” he reminded me. “Villain, but still human. It’s all right to want things for yourself, Catherine.”
>Do not try to become me,” he said. “I was a tool that served a purpose, and that purpose is coming to an end.
…his best kind of sucked.
“Do as I say, not as I do” -_-
Black’s taught Cat better than to be accidentally suicidal. Unfortunately, he also taught her the exact method for being that on purpose -_-
LikeLiked by 8 people
You’re right… let’s hope the Woe puts a kibosh on any self sacrifice plans, then.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Well, the Calamities’ approach to that sure as fuck didn’t work (and was actually somewhat coutnerproductive as they antagonized Cat instead of coordinating the common “stop doing this” intervention).
Here’s hope the Woe is going to do better.
Indrani’s certainly been making a decent sounding board / therapist throughout Book 4, though now it’s time for Catherine to play that for her right back.
Can’t wait for Catherine to encounter the mirror image of her own bullshit in Hakram No-Hands and realize that it’s contagious and that maybe she should stop ;u;
LikeLiked by 2 people
They could be a circus trio: Hakram No-Hands, Zeze Glass-Eyes and Cat Peg-Leg.
Really, Thief and Archer are the ones missing out. Come on, girls! Time to lose a nose or ear!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Don’t forget Akua, the No Body.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Good catch! Though I’d call her Akua No-Heart. Feels more pungent like that.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Akua the Bodyless
LikeLiked by 1 person
Dramatically lowered risk now that she’s not named.
An evil villian sparing a hero out of finding their death tedious births the one that will kill them.
A mundane (technically) General beating a youngster, teaming up with that youngster, and then getting killed by them? That is only the kind of story a villian has. Unless he wants to soil his entire family’s legacy, he has until the alliance to take care of her.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yup.
The crucial difference is the kind of motivation the (potential) hero has for opposing the (hypothetical) villain. If the insult of defeat is the only sticking point, there’s no story there and the defeated youngster just has to suck it up. But if the insult of defeat is only the inciting incident for the hero slowly noticing all the other good reasons to oppose the villain, well, then the narrative gears click into motion.
If Cat isn’t a villainous Named, that’s that much less good reason to oppose her. If Cat succeeds in her alliance efforts, that’s that much less good reason to oppose her. Depending on how Cat does politically / narrative wise from now on, period, that’s going to determine how much story weight the kid’s going to have for potentially opposing her.
And something (like her own inner monologue) tells me that Cat’s more than willing to accept this kind of check on her future actions.
LikeLike
Well, as Amadeus has demonstrated to his own great surprise, Mentor Occupational Hazard is not the only possible outcome, just the most straightforward one.
Leaving like “kthxbye you can handle this without me now I’m off on vacation” is a succession trope, too.
LikeLiked by 7 people
True, though mentors who do that have a tendency to return at the end of the second act to perform a heroic sacrifice, or turn out to be the big bad.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Yep.
On the other hand, there’s an expanded version of that trope.
““I’m not explaining myself right,” she said. “Just – all right, think about it like this. Hero out on their first lark, meets a mysterious helpful stranger that gives advice and maybe teaches a trick. When’s the next time you see them?”
My fingers clenched.
“When that hero’s in over their head,” I said softly. “When the stranger appears out of nowhere and wipes the floor with the villain, enough that the hero can flee and prepare for the rematch.”
“Yeah,” Vivienne agreed grimly. “That’s the thing, Cat. He doesn’t always win, but I couldn’t find a single instance of when the Grey Pilgrim got into a fight and lost.””
It’s a risky story to have. But given its utility for those you want to help, I 100% see Catherine going for it.
50% chance of heroic sacrifice, 50% chance of helping and surviving to do it another time? Cat’s snapping that deal up.
LikeLiked by 6 people
Unsure she gets do be the helpful stranger when she’s been the woman’s superior for years, but, if anyone can swing that, it’s Cat.
LikeLiked by 1 person
“Turn out to be the Big Bad” is still on the table.
LikeLike
That case tends to lead to the young hero killing their mentor, tho.
LikeLiked by 1 person
With regard to Catherine?
Let’s be real.
No ;u;
LikeLike
Abigail is gonna end up the next queen at this rate, and hate every second of it.
LikeLiked by 13 people
And the horrible thing is, she can see it coming!
LikeLiked by 3 people
How is old Cat again? Why is she always like so young she is like 20 or 21 max? She started this story at like 17, I dont remember how many years the story has been going off. But it seems odd she comment that Abigail and this Lord are so young. I guess it suppose to show she feels old.
Still Abigail getting some tutoring and Cat doesn’t think the Lord did anything wrong. I suppose his mistake was not believing the rumors from when Cat dropped a Lake. But then again we dont know who told him that information or where they got it from. You could say he was arrogant if he heard it straight from Saint or Pilgrim not that I think they told him. But he doesn’t seem to have access to an intelligence so not trusting the source with his information isn’t necessarily bad.
Are we getting a funeral? Or do we switch to a new character? Also what is Indrani doing and did Cat tell her about Masego yet.
LikeLiked by 2 people
It feels like we are in for a bit of info dump then the classic EE twist of some kind at the end.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Yeah, he just heard rumors. And those aren’t very trustworthy – in the early chapters Cat referred to all sorts of fanciful rumors about Black.
LikeLiked by 3 people
And then some of them turned out to be actually true, like the dragon one. And no way to tell which is which.
(Well, the giant’s blood one is easy once you’ve met him…)
LikeLiked by 5 people
Maybe it was a short giant, okay? XD
LikeLiked by 4 people
Catherine is 21, and started at 15 going on 16.
It’s definitely a trick of perception that her own age peers seem young to her. Catherine’s commented on it before. A lot of people have been horrified by how young she is too – I particularly remember Tariq and Brandon Talbot. It’s not actually normal to have her level of experience/ptsd at her age. Cat’s not wrong to comment on how insanely young Abigail is, it’s not weakened by the fact she’s young too. Both things can be horrifying at the same time.
And yeah, I don’t think Tanja did that bad as a commander either. He didn’t have reliable intelligence. Throw away hindsight bias and consider things from his perspective. This is Catherine being bane to rational thinking, not him being irrational.
Indrani’s probably with the rest of the drow army that’s catching up.
LikeLiked by 6 people
I say its weird in a real world but not in the narrative world ie Heroes and Villains usually start their rise pretty young. I mean Amadeus and Weseka started their rise even younger then Cat and the Woe. Add to fact we have turnover from wars and narrative based conflicts and the fact that Cat broke away from Praes which means most of her team is younger naturally. Young people being at key positions at the start of every major realignment doesn’t seem unusual.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m not even sure it’s all that weird in the real world, if we look back through history towards earlier times. Though don’t quote me on this ofc I’m not a historian.
LikeLike
Uncommon but not weird. Even in America, it was only recently (well into the 20th century) that a 15-year old would really be considered “a child” — that transition followed the spreading demand for schooling beyond basic literacy and arithmetic.
For most of human history, a 15-year-old would likely be married (or at least betrothed), and would certainly be working at adult tasks. They’d still be noted as (probably) being physically weaker, and mentally less mature, than a 20- or 30-year-old (see age requirements for public office; USA), but they would be sitting at the grownups’ table. And yeah, there’s a fair number of European kings and queens who took power in their teens.
LikeLiked by 1 person
And Names were explicitly noted early on, as a way for surprisingly young people to gain power and achieve mighty things.
LikeLiked by 2 people
On the other hand, it was Black himself that taught Catherine that mundane numbers could overwhelm Named pretty easily. One of his first lessons was a story about predecessor Black Knights with enough power to make him look like a child, who died to a common soldier’s blade after running out of stamina.
10:1 numbers advantage is nothing to scoff at. He was completely right to think he could beat Catherine in a brawl right there, his main mistake was not reading the terrain.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yep.
LikeLike
More fundamentally, Razin Tanja did not consider at all the chance that the enemy commander had a magical trick up their sleeve, and this despite her odd behavior, dire reputation, and minions of an unfamiliar species. In a world where such tricks are widespread and well-known (including not just Named, but “ordinary” mages and priests), that’s not just failing to be genre-savvy, it’s downright ignorant.
LikeLiked by 1 person
He did not exactly have a free hour to slowly and thoughtfully deliberate on the situation.
He had to make a snap decision. The Black Queen’s right there. Maybe if he waits that’s all the time she needs to weave a slower evil spell to destroy all his troops. Maybe she’s baiting him and the trick she has will be greatly weakened if he doesn’t attack. Maybe she’s banking on him thinking that and bluffing a trick where there isn’t one. Maybe-
He did not have enough information to make an informed decision, period. Criticizing his guesses is pointless. If he waited and let her set up – and it was something she needed to set up for – it’d be just as delicious to jump in like ‘oooh Cat was underestimated again’.
Hindsight bias.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Self-correction: “At all” –> “until much too late”.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m wondering if Nauk might in fact get raised as some sort of undead. Resurrection by Good probably isn’t in the cards, but as noted with the zombie horses, a non-aligned power can do better than the usual zombie or wight.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Correct me if im wrong but Cat is no longer named right?
LikeLiked by 2 people
She does not have a direct Mantle, but she probably still works within the bounds of Story. She’s far more flexible than any of her peers, but she’s still directed somewhat.
LikeLiked by 1 person
My suspicion is that she either has or is devloping one of those original “Names” that were seen in the memories in the Fae Realm. The ones that were more like bestowed general powers but lacked definition.
It does make me wonder who the Squire is right now. Wonder if that’ll be Abigail, haha!
LikeLike
She no longer has a Name, yeah.
LikeLike
Cat just let a promising young leader go, while starting to mentor her own.
Oh snap, is she setting up multiple death flags for herself?
LikeLiked by 10 people
My hope is that the young man doesn’t have the narrative weight to actually set up a pattern with her – she’s playing the big leagues with th Dead King, Cordelia and Malicia, while he’s a small time general. And she didn’t commit any atrocities that might justify a rise to Hero status.
On Abigail… I say she needs to take care that they don’t have a Mentor-Apprentice relationship. Perhaps by tutoring other people – seems to work for the Pilgrim – or by not involving herself too much… or maybe by changing their relationship. It has been some time since she last took a lover.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Patterns of three only apply to rivals.
How in the unholy fuck is Tanyusha McGloryHound a rival for Catherine? They’re not in the same dismension. He’s not Named, she’s not a noble, their goals don’t either intesect or contradict each other?
Story thinking overcomplicates this. Catherine just earned herself an enemy. It’s one person, and matters the way one person who’s got some political weight does.
LikeLiked by 3 people
A young, talented prince, out on his first campaign, sees his men brutally murdered by the foul magics of the cruel Black Queen (btw, she *is* a noble) …and swears revenge for their deaths.
After a long journey, where he accrues friends, allies, and knowledge, he finally faces her on the battlefield, prepared to vanquish the foe that appears in his nightmares to this day.
Tell me that’s not a common archetype.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I’m sorry but “Queen Foundling” remains a punchline ;u; (and a deliberate one at that)
And no, it’s not common. “Sees his men brutally murdered by the foul magics of the cruel Black Queen” just doesn’t quite cut it for the Call.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Well, nominal roles like that do matter for stories and politics. It’s why there was so much debate about what things would be called after the Battle of Camps.
As for the Call, I hope it doesn’t count.
LikeLike
True!
It’s still a punchline, which I appreciated anew once I remembered the word for foundling in Russian and started thinking of Catherine as that. You get used to how it sounds and stop really appreciating what kind of last name it really is ;u;
LikeLiked by 1 person
Google Translate gave me these: подкидыш, найденыш
Unsure how either makes it funnier.
Or did you not know what Foundling meant?
LikeLike
Катерина Найдёныш, Леди Найдёныш, Её Величество Найдёныш.
It worked for me because over time I got used to thinking of “Foundling” as just a last name, a neutral sequence of syllables. But it’s not. In-universe, it’s not, because it’s the last name given to all orphans. It’s a signifier of Catherine being an orphan, of her having no lineage and no known ancestors.
Translating into Russian refreshed my perception of that and made me appreciate the surreality of the situation anew 😛
(And part of the surreality is that instead of taking a new last name or looking for her ancestors, Catherine sticks with the ‘orphan’ identifier. She’s not playing the game where orphans are at the bottom and royalty is at the top, where given a chance you disentangle yourself from being an orphan and clutch at the royalty thing with all you have. Catherine stays loyal to her origins, takes pride in them, and that’s really the punchline part)
(“The closest thing I have to a father is down south killing fools, and he doesn’t have a last name. Born a farmer, you see”)
(never fucking forget)
LikeLiked by 2 people
Quite possibly, once upon a time, but a few problems now:
1. SHE’S NOT NAMED. If she was a villian, shed’ have birthd a new hero. But she’s not. Maybe she’ll be one again someday, but right now she’s just some human with tricks.
2. She’s going to be his ally. Or at least an ally of his allies. That’s her whole actual goal her. Coming back to defeat the Black Queen who’s invading your country? Very common archtype, yes. Bu by the time you come back… she’s the friend of your friend and is attacking your enemy side by side. And the types of people who kill that person… they aren’t heroes. And the bratty noble who can’t put his own personal need for vengeance aside for the greater good of all, including themselves? The archetype is they die trying to get that vengeance, not succeeding. If Cat’s a named again by this point, he’s more screwed. If she doesn’t have one… then it’s a boy who either has become a villian but is doing this against somebody who see’s him coming a mile away and can still hit about his weight class… or he’s a mundane doing this against somebody who still saw him coming a mile away who can hit even harder above his weight class.
Basically he has till she can get Cordelia to play nice to pull anything off if he wants narrative help, which he absolutely needs, and after that unless she acts wildly out of character he’s shit out of luck. At that point at best he can be the background character that helps somebody with better odds get a shot at her.
LikeLiked by 2 people
1. I addressed this in another comment, but she has enough weight, she should be affected by tropes. If that’s not enough, she’s bound to two goddesses (and we know apotheosis binds one to patterns) and a band of Named, plus an eldritch fae thing. Not being Named herself is a minor consideration.
2. There are other forces arraying against this maneuver. The Saint, mostly, but she seems to be working with the Bard. And the Bard is suspected to have the ear of the Oracle. It is very possible that the prince becomes their ally or pawn when this all comes to a head.
LikeLike
There’s hardly more reason to think Bard would want Catherine dead than reason to think Bard would want Catherine alive.
LikeLiked by 1 person
We know she worked with Saint on the declaration of Cat as arch heretic. So while we don’t know the Bard wants her dead, we know the old monster doesn’t seem to want the Accords signed.
LikeLike
We also know she prevented the elves from killing Akua, doesn’t mean she wanted Akua to beat Catherine.
Bard works in indirect ways.
And I think there’s good reason to consider that it might be possible that Liesse Accords being successfully signed is exactly what she’s after, considering her comments to Anaxares about the League and considering how she engineered Second Liesse and its outcome
LikeLiked by 1 person
Point. I suspect her thing with Akua was letting evil wreck itself. Akua’s plan drove a wedge between Black and the Empress; it provided fodder for the Crusade; it led Cat into delving fully into Winter (ie nerfed her in all the ways that mattered); it, eventually, resulted in the Dead King marching and this ultimate conflict between Good and Evil. So no, I don’t think Bard is very favorable towards an international agreement to stop the infighting.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You’re thinking too short term. My point is that Bard plays the long game. The Dead King sure is looking more and more like the perfect pretext for an alliance between all other forces on the continent, Good or Evil. The Arch-Heretic thing isn’t going to seriously stand in the way of Catherine steamrolling her way into an eventual alliance with 50k drow, is my prediction. It could, later, after the Dead King was defeated, but as someone on reddit said, it’s like triggering an avalanche deliberately so it’s not as bad as if it happened later. Bringing up the Arch-Heretic point when it’s frankly stupid defuses the question.
Bard’s problem with the League was that it was ‘skin deep’ and ‘none of the forces behind it moved any differently after foundation’.
Cat’s trying to make Liesse Accords the foundation for the future, period. To base a new continent-wide status quo on them.
All the immediate conflicts Bard’s fanning are petty in the face of the possibility of that.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t see what the arch heretic thing does to help, tho. The drow thing? Sure. Not declaring her arch heretic.
LikeLike
Catherine kept looking for an easy way out of things.
Ally with the Crusade, go against Malicia, be forced to make concessions and abandon her grander plan but end the war early.
The Arch-Heretic thing drives her into the corner where she HAS to bend everyone else to her will, there’s literally no other way left open in the direction she wants to go.
And at the same time, see the point she brings up in the latest chapter. The thing about being declared Arch-Heretic early in the war is that you completely lack leverage afterwards. If the Crusade is forced to chew and swallow working with the person they’ve already declared Arch-Heretic, that breaks a big Good vs Evil trope, and that aligns with what I’m guessing Bard’s point is here perfectly.
Again, Catherine, when forced between, say, abdicating during a peaceful time and shattering the House of Light in half by being declared Arch-Heretic, would most definitely not choose the latter. Now that the catastrophe already happened in Cat’s absence (twice, even), she has no incentive left to back down, now or later.
LikeLike
Did she really? I’m pretty sure she never once considered giving up on the Accords. Which would have been much easier to get signed without this – Cordelia was almost 100% for signing them when this came along.
LikeLike
I’m not sure about this, I admit. This is how I remember things going.
I don’t think Cordelia /knew/ about Liesse Accords. She was considering burning her own political capital to demand that Catherine be let into the Grand Alliance, but the Liesse Accords have yet to come up between them, I think.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t think Cat put the entirety of the Accords to her, but they’d been speaking for a while, so she had some idea where Cat was going.
And if she was letting Cat into the Alliance, it was a short walk from there to the Accords. Gotta remember Cordelia is not actually expansionist.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah, I do remember that. I just get the impression that Catherine didn’t make a whole lot of progress in those talks.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I merely meant that her being ready to let Cat into the Alliance, knowing some of her ideas, signals some openness to them.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I mean yeah, agreed strongly. Cordelia and Catherine are more or less on the same page for a lot of stuff.
Cordelia just doesn’t (didn’t) have the Named momentum to just go straight for the goal and fuck everyone who’s in the way. (And it is in fact a point of pride to her that she actually discussed with Cat – or it was lmao)
LikeLiked by 1 person
Cordelia doesn’t need a Name to get things done. That’s the way of Procer – they’re one of the strongest countries on Calernia, and they’re not led by Named.
What Cordelia has is a strong will and political acumen. Plus the loyal people from her home.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I mean, yea. Procer is not led by Named, they’re led by something vaguely resembling democracy on the highest level, and Cordelia made a whole point out of defending that system to Catherine.
Named drive right through obstacles to arrive at their desired outcome. Cordelia has to temper her means and ends in accordance to other people’s wills.
In these particular circumstances, I suspect this might end up insufficient to carry out her duty :3
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s an oligarchy.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah.
LikeLike
It’s not helping, no. It’s not what Catherine wants. She’s not so confident in her Accords project that she’ll fight the whole continent for it, given alternative.
Bard isn’t trying to help, here, any more than she was helping Hanno in the Free Cities.
LikeLike
Is she not? She seemed pretty good with it… and really, she wouldn’t need to fight nearly as many people if it weren’t for this declaration.
LikeLiked by 1 person
True.
Bard’s irons in the fire might also include Laurence’s point about Procer being rotten and needing to be broken and rebuilt. And I would say Bard has very different ideas than Laurence does about how things are going to go and what the rseult is going to look like.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That sounded less like it getting rebuild and more like something else being built on its ashes…
LikeLike
Considering it’s a metaphor either way and nobody’s going to literally turn it into a scorched wasteland (not even the Dead King, he’s after the living, not blighting the land), the point is highly abstract.
Either way, the Arch-Heretic thing, while not making anyone involved happy, has proven to be insufficient to stop Catherine. That, to me, means it cannot be used as proof that Bard intended for it to.
This does largely boil down to the question of how competent Bard really is. We know she’s told Neshamah that flipping the story on Cat hasn’t worked, but I’m not sure that that refers to trying to kill her and not, say, trying to convert her to Good?… Because one of those tasks is much easier&simpler than the other.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You may recall that Neshamah did blight his land. The lands around the Crown a egg e filled with poison.
In any case, many people are likely to die because of this arch heretic thing. And, well, it hasn’t stopped Cat – which makes sense, she only heard about it recently – but it has complicated her ability to conduct diplomacy by a lot.
LikeLike
That’s Keter’s Due, not intentional.
And we’ll see how it plays out :3
LikeLike
Are you telling me you don’t think he could have cleaned some of that up over the millennia?
It’s advantageous for him. The dead don’t need to breathe, and he has all the territory he needs in his Serenity.
LikeLike
I mean, yeah. I’m just saying the Dead King is not aiming to blight the Principate too – it’d be to his disadvantage even, he wants living humans right there where he can get them :3
LikeLiked by 1 person
Why would he? I imagine he has all the people he needs in the Serenity. I suspect that more than anything he wants a larger buffer so the Intercessor has a harder time interfering with his plans.
LikeLike
Exactly, why would he burn the land?
LikeLike
I meant “why would he want those people?”. Burning the land would make it more difficult for both armies and Named to reach Keter to interfere with his stuff, avoid the possibility of rebellion – a possibility since the new territory is not as controlled as the Serenity – discourage attempts to reconquer the land…
LikeLike
Yup.
LikeLike
is she still in the same league as the big players? just some river cracking nearly floored her and daylight is severly limitting her. Not to mention she has a mortal body again. Comparing to the battle of camps. this battle was a regression of her battle ability. No turning to mist again, no healing after getting cut by the saint of swords.
LikeLike
Her personal badass level is a lot lower, but as others have noted (including in-story), that personal power was never her true strength — if anything, it was a distraction from her mastery of narrative and strategic brilliance.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Belatedly: Also, the text notes that the goddess powering her “withdrew her power roughly”, which might well warrant a “hey, not cool” in later discussion with them.
LikeLiked by 1 person
This is probably a skill thing. Komena isn’t exactly practiced in empowering her chosen priestess to perform large scale miracles.
They’ll get better at this with time, IMHO.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Cat did comment that being “First” was less about being most powerful, than about being the one to clear the path.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yep.
The white mouse 🙂
LikeLike
On the other hand, her power is now versatile and doesn’t come with sanity erosion as a drawback.
And then there’s the fact that tricks are ultimately still tricks – it was the army that won this skirmish, the power just helped minimize casualties further.
Political power, the power of who you have at your side, the power of having an army and allies, matters a lot more than what 1 person can do in a 1v1 battle. Or even a 1vArmy battle – even if you destroy anything in your field of vision, your field of vision is still only so much. Named cannot hold territory.
LikeLike
How is her Power more versatile? She lost an invulnerable Body, making her body to mist, raising sentinent Undead, making potential immortal Fae soldiers, she cannot Gate without Restriction anymore and she is severly limmited when the Sun shines. For now the only New use of Night, which she couldnt do with Winter, was her lighting her Pipe.
Her oppening a gate at the battle of camps was the deciding factor to even the playing field and you call it a trick…you know what would minimize casualities even further? instead going through flames like a retard use a gate. oh wait doesnt work anymore, because she is tired after gating with night. More Power would help her preserve her army even better, so the odds she wins are better.
Political power matters way less than you thinkg, look how it went for Cordelia and why do you think Cat has now more? she has even less than before, because to reach her Goal of Peace allying with murderous Nightworshipping Drow will just prove them right she is the Archheretic. the only Thing she gained in the Everdark besides snarky Ravens, is an Army. And an Army is per definition NOT Political Power, but Martial Power.
And the as of now End Boss of this arc, The Dead King, has build a Kingdom and an army of Dead, with his own power, which lasted for over a Millenium. And look how long he held his territory. It even expanded under his rule.
When she is fighting the big Names, she NEEDS more power. The gulf of Power which seperates the Dead King from an ordinary Named is even greater than the Power gulf between a Named and a Non Named. Again Quote from the earlier Books, there is a point where Power is so much greater that no amount of tricks can even the playing field.
I think people understand something wrong, In the past, when she won unwinnable Battles she tricked the Story, so Creation MADE her more powerful, so she could win. Look how the Encounter went against Akua and William, she suddenly was better. When she outplayed the summer Queen she withstood her might a lot easier than when she first met the Winter King. At second Liesse, the moment she was the unleashed Monster storywise, she tore out Akuas Heart in one Move, where she lost before. This Hints that personal Power is in some way NECESSARY to win in Creation, as its not logical for a absolute weakling to win insurmountable odds.
LikeLike
So considering all of the above and Cats Goals (killing Saint, defeating Cordelia, Pilgrim and then the Dead King) It is highly unlikely she wins without some power up. (Masego showing up and working a miracle is my bet).
LikeLike
Well, I’m betting she’s going to do just fine in her current state.
We’ll see who’s right!
LikeLike
>as its not logical for a absolute weakling to win insurmountable odds
So are you assering that Catherine isn’t going to win, that she’s not an absolute weakling, or that Guide is illogical?
LikeLike
I am asserting that if a Victory was achieved in Creation, yet the Winner lacks the power to complete the Victory, Creation will make Winner more powerful.
LikeLike
Huh.
Okay.
So what you’re saying is that it doesn’t matter that Cat has given up on Winter, Creation’s going to empower her either way as long as she’s winning?
LikeLike
I am saying if she needs more power than she has now to win. We will see how she gets it
LikeLike
I’m not sure what the cause effect chain is that you’re thinking of. Cat can’t win unless she gets more power? Cat can’t not get more power?
LikeLike
I think what you’re saying is that if the Story/Narrative says you win, then you’re empowered such that you win.
And while there’s some truth to that … there are also limits.
The Narrative boost won’t overcome everything.
As an analogy, the boost won’t enable an unathletic 400 pound couch potato to outsprint Usain Bolt in his prime. It could enable a pro NFL player to do so. It might allow a good collegiate or high school level athlete to compete and not get blown away.
That’s how Black pulled off the Conquest – he set things up so that the Narrative boost that Callow got for being Good wasn’t enough.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Narrative power trumps all other forms of it though. And that’s what she always has the most of.
But you underestimate what she can do. Yes, she can “only” collapse a river now, in daytime when it’s established she’s much weaker. But she is fully sane after using it, just tired. So she’s not making dumb mistakes and marching off into a stupider situation because she’s oh so strong. Remember winter cat? Yeah, she could shrug off being cut apart. And she was walking into fights with the one woman who could cut her and make it stick!
Sheer named power wins BATTLES. but how many times has the much more powerful villain won battle after battle and then lost the war right at the end? That’s every black night before Amadeus. Yeah, they were real great right up till the endgame. Which is exactly what happened to Cat at her most powerful, don’t forget. The everdark was her strongest period and she was marching right to her death, saved only by the fact that her power bled out. She won that at her literal weakest, a dying frail mortal.
And that’s why having the narrative matters. The Dead King is a master of the narrative, which is how he’s lasted this long. But if there’s anybody on this playing field who can make him fuck up in the way that leads him to his own destruction, well… your calling her weak and saying she needs more powerups.
LikeLiked by 2 people
just tired… did you read how she nearly fell down unconcious? you mean “enslaved” after she gave up her claim on winter. She wasnt saved, she begged for mercy and Sve noc granted it.
So you tell me winter cat was stupid…what would Cripple Cat have done? how would the battle of camps have went with Cat as she is now. how would she have fared in Keter as she is now? she would have been destroyed without a chance.
Power itself and the application of Power are the same. so Amadeus is the most powerful Black knight in history. Why does Amadeus come into the discussion about Cats power? everything he uses to win except power is Cat sorely lacking.
The Dead King is a master of Narrative AND powerful, so Cat stands no Chance, as she is certainly less powerful. Neshama was for over 1000 Years in conflict with the bard, no way he gets outwitted by Cat.
LikeLike
Her battle ability isn’t really what got her into the big leagues, anyways. It was her ability to win battles she had no business winning, plus Neshamah’s interest in potential apotheosis.
She’s in the big leagues because she fights people on the big leagues. I mean, Malicia is not a great fighter, and Cordelia is not even Named!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yet she only won those Battles because she was powerful enough. The Fae got defeated because she joined the Winter Court, she defeated Akua when she embraced Winter fully, Battle of Camps using Gates, The Dead King only invited her for her Power not anything else and she became a threat to Sve Noc BECAUSE of her Power to bind the drow to her. Now she lacks that Power and instead got Night which is half the time useless (Daytime) and she can get offed like any other mortal. what will keep her in the big leagues now that she has less Power?
LikeLike
Her position? Her team? Her knowledge of narrative, which is actually what defeated the fairies, and the lack of which actually put her in the situation of losing to Akua (and was also what she exploited to make sure ripping out Masego’s work killed Akua)?
Really, if anything Fakerine, with her limited thinking and ability to innovate, was inferior to plain old Cat in many respects.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yet she needed the power before she could use the power of narrative. Without being of winter, the winter fairies wouldnt have helped her, she would have never stopped Akua without her gates. Cat thougth herself while on campaign its good she has the power to do stuff and even Akua said she was difficult to take down as the last of winter. And the loss was baited by Black. The win came with embracimg winter fully She was clearly not Fakerine as she held the mantle not long enough. Thats what Sve Noc said. Good old Cat got her leg crippled from stupidity and instead of owning the mosnter she flinches back from power.
LikeLike
She lost the fight against Akua by outsmarting herself – bringing the fight against Diabolist to Arcadia.
As for power? Look at Black. Great combat power is a red herring. Cat got the fae to help her because of political play and alliances. Her personal power was minimal (and in the end she was being played anyways).
Sve Noc wanted to blame her. And yeah, Fakerine was still built out of Cat. But when you look at what she thought when she became mortal again… it’s what she always feared when she looked at the fae: it didn’t really care about Cat’s ideals. It danced the dance by playing the role of Cat.
LikeLiked by 1 person
When you say cat was limited in her thinking and innovation ability, you clearly think lame Cat would have done things differently. What would she have done different? What would she have done better? We dont know,as it is not written. its just your unreasonable hate of Winter Cat interpreting things which arent there.
LikeLike
We have been told in story at least one dwarf thought she was more dangerous as a mortal. I think that’s going to pan out. I think shes going to win in places Winter cat could not have. That she.doesnt do it as directly is irrelevant as long as she wins.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s not unreasonable hate. It’s knowledge that she was a fae version of herself, plus knowledge of how fae are limited.
And while we don’t know what Cat would have done, that doesn’t mean we can’t know she would have done things differently.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s kinda been her intent since ages ago.
She’s wanted to abdicate for ages, but there’s never been someone good enough to actually hold the crown after her.
LikeLiked by 3 people
She might be going for the … Dread Emperor Irritant (I think) method of comboing multiple sources of inevitable doom into multiple sources of advoidable doom.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Catherine is certainly not prioritizing her own safety here.
I don’t think these death flags are that dire, though. They’re non-zero, but there’s a lot of narrative weight to Cat surviving at this point.
LikeLike
Surviving, or outright coming back from the dead… again.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I know I’m really jumping the gun here, but the italicized taught at the end seemed almost aspect-ish. Probably just wishful think though.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Ohhhhh, now wouldn’t that just be a fascinating aspect, especially as a priest?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Nah, it’s a callback how to her first Aspect ever, was Learn.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Good catch. Though those tend to come in bold.
More likely it’s just a reference to how rigorous the teaching will be.
LikeLike
It’s most definitely just emphasis. “I can’t just dump responsibility on her, I have to actually teach her if I want this to go well”.
Doesn’t mean Cat isn’t going to get a Name out of it ^^
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t understand why a priest cannot heal Catherine’s leg. Are they not supposed to heal anything not congenital?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Probably because she’s got Night running through her veins.
Trying to heal her with Light is more likely to blow her up than heal her.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Her leg was initially damaged by necromancy, healed imperfectly, left that way for years, vanished entirely as she ceased having a physical leg, and then got returned specifically because the universe/narrative apparently decided it was an intrinsic part of her mortality. Any one of those seems like it’d be a legit reason that priests couldn’t heal it, but all together it means I’d be surprised could be healed at all by *anyone*, anymore than the Grey Pilgrim gets to have not-grey clothing.
LikeLiked by 12 people
The bad leg is so heavily integrated into her story that conventional healing won’t work anymore. It part of her, symbolizing her regained mortality.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Also, the leg is a story trope in its own right — q.v. the Fisher King motif, though in the original it had other implications. If the Fisher King pattern does apply, Callow cannot be healed until Catherine is either healed by a Higher Power (nope) or replaced by someone without such an intrinsic wound.
That said, the original FK’s wound was (probably) a specifically male trope, somewhat bowdlerized in transmission. In direct contrast, Cat was specifically noted as having regained not only her mortality, but also her fertility. And that allows for a number of longer-term tropes….
LikeLiked by 2 people
Her wound is part of her identity. It was Story Significant. Much like the scar she gave Black, it’s here to stay.
She may not be Named, but she’s still got enough weight and involvement with Below that she’s bound to narrative rules.
LikeLiked by 3 people
I think at this point the leg counts as congenital, considering it was involved in Cat’s very soul being mutilated.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I wonder if the leg ties into Cat being Suicidal all the time and not really thinking about herself in the longterm. I figure if she does start valuing surviving and not constantly trying to abdicate and foist the Post Liesse Accord world order on to others that the limb would heal.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oof.
Welcome to Akua’s Worry Club.
Though I don’t think that even if you’re right the leg would heal entirely. That’d just be… bland. Hurting much less, only getting in the way of actually fighitng / dancing, I can see that though.
LikeLike
It’s the opposite actually. It will never get in the way of fighting, she will always have some trick to at least put the pain off and fight at her full potential.
But afterwards, it will always remind her how frail and human she is as long as she is indeed a human.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’d say it’s going to get in the way of fighting always. A trick she uses to put off the pain is a trick she could have used otherwise. It’s a handicap, period.
And I think she’ll keep it as such.
LikeLike
Nah, narration hates that. Itd be different if the one who wounded her or their team still lived, then the old injury having mattered might, well, matter, but theres no good story in “then that knee of mine i fucked up years ago flared up so I lost.”
LikeLike
I mean, nobody writes it like your example. “I dropped to one knee, cursing my bad leg. The sword passed right above my head, cutting off stray hairs,”
There are fun ways to write disability, you’re just not thinking of them :3
LikeLike
Oh my. We might be getting Nauk back! Also, those Abigail POV’s are paying up big time. Chekhov’s firing squad right there. Not only is she her first Callowan general, she’s also Cat’s apprentice.
I’m still so excited for Cat to meet up with the rest of the Woe… it’s been too long, and EE has been super evil and left us hanging on Vivi and Hakram AND Masego.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Nauk is super dead. Cat’s sending Robber to do a proper funeral for him.
LikeLiked by 6 people
Doesn’t sound like it, with the way she asked. But you may be right.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah, the way things are shaping up, it’s either Indrani or Zeze getting a tragic ending (less on Indrani though, considering she may peace out of the party Ranger-style). Though if the worst comes to pass, I hope we can get a reunion with the whole Woe before that.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I really, really, really don’t think any of Woe are going to die.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Until the book 6 at least.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Not even then, I think. The Calamities are getting killed off because their successors are on-scene.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Agreed.
LikeLike
Yeah we’re aiming for a big “everyone reunites and everything has changed but really it’s all the same in the ways that matter” trope.
LikeLiked by 2 people
nice bit of story, i really enjoyed Cat’s interactions w/ folks.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Cat left him alive to fight the Dead King and if he comes for revenge later, well he will be breaking the Accords that she is setting up which will probably end up badly for him both personally and for Levent politically
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m not sure the Accords are going to directly specify alliance / forbiddance of aggression. Now if he were to summon a demon to go after Cat…
LikeLike
From what I understood from Cat’s little talk with Pilgrim in Chapter 8 of Book 4, the goal of the Accords is to limit the influence of Named (of all kinds) and their ability to acquire resources, basically rendering them incapable of waging ideological wars they’re so fond of.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Would sidelining Named really bring peace to Calernia? We have none, and are not driven by Narrative shackles or capricious, warring Gods. Yet, we still have our fair share of ideological wars, and every other kind for that matter.
If Cat’s Accords are just about removing Named from positions of power, then she lacks a sufficient understanding of human nature. Heroes might be driving the Crusade into the ground, but they are not alone in fault, nor the ones who called for it to begin with.
LikeLike
That I do not know. I can’t speak of the full extent of the Liesse Accords. That’s just what I gathered from that conversation.
LikeLike
I don’t think Cat’s going to filter by absence/presence of Name. Just by actions and their consequences.
LikeLike
Something on that scale, yeah.
LikeLike
Having reread the chapter: The only direct mention of Named is between the failed bargain and the successful one. Initially:
1) Cat offers direct aid against the Tower, abdication, and other concessions, in exchange for Callow not being taken over by Procer’s nobles.
2) Pilgrim’s response is “I do not rule Procer”, and says he’d have to actually fight Procer to enforce that.
3) Cat points out that yeah, she’d have to fight a civil war to enforce her side too.
4) But Pilgrim still isn’t buying: “For such a thing to hold, there would be need for trust where none exists”.
At that point, Cat comes out with:
> “Every single Named is a highly dangerous weapon, in their own way,” I said. “Any unwilling to accept constraints placed on their actions have no business wielding that kind of power in the first place. And before you ask, I do not exclude myself or any ally of mine from that statement.” (Implied: And that goes for you too, Pilgrim.)
And that leads to the agreement Cat does get: No sacking of cities, no abuse of prisoners (including greenskins) and no summoning demons or devils, in exchange for no angels: “We can’t prevent escalation if your bargaining position is that we fold but you don’t.” She even tosses in the location of Callow’s last Hell Egg as a show of good faith; that is, she wants that thing gone too, and the forces of Good are better equipped to destroy it (which they do).
LikeLiked by 2 people
Giving the result of all my previous guesses for where the story will turn next, I can say that Abigail will not be the queen. I am half sure that EE just reads our fan theories and does the exact opposite.
LikeLiked by 2 people
There have been correct theories!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Cat is Best Cleric.
LikeLiked by 1 person
HEY CATHERINE, LOOKS LIKE WE”VE GOT ALL THE SOLDIERS!!!”
“HEY LEVANTINES!! LOOKS LIKE YOU”RE ON THE WRONG SIDE OF THE RIIIIVVVEEERRRRR”
LikeLiked by 4 people
I love you.
LikeLike
Cracking a frozen river would have been next to nothing under Winter. The fact that this relatively minor use of power left Cat so vulnerable makes me think that she is significantly weaker now. If she tried fighting Heroes like at Five Camps, she would be dead several times over. Yes she can enjoy mortal vices again, but the sheer quantity of power she has given up is very significant.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Her power is more situational now. We don’t know yet how strong she is under cover of night — this was using the power of darkness in broad daylight.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Her positioning has changed though.
The most cleanly won battle is one you never fight.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That would be fine if she was a once-in-a-generation strategist like Juniper. Cat has good battle sense from experience, but is otherwise above average at best. Her place is a mix of ‘big picture’ and ‘hammer’, except now she can’t even do the latter.
LikeLike
I make a distinction between Catherine and Juniper in that one’s a strategist and the other’s a tactician.
Note how the five-way melee led to a stalemate between the objectively best company and the objectively worst company (just in degree of the troops’ skill), and ended up with Catherine achieving her goal in full.
Juniper’s a tactician. Give her a battle, give her resources, and she’ll make the best out of what she has.
Cat’s a strategist. Give her a war, give her a country, and she’ll make sure that all the battles and resources available for them are skewed in her favor.
If the best tactician in the world is running out of supplies, they lose, and the strategist that drove them into that corner wins.
Cat’s a strategist. She thinks a meta level higher. See Juniper’s own assessment:
“When historians try to pin down Foundling’s methods they point to the Battle of the Camps or the Princes’ Graveyard, but those came later. After she’d learned her trade. If you want to understand how she operated, look to the Battle of Four Armies and One – from the beginning to the end, she was playing an entirely different game from every other commander on the field.”
– Extract from “A Commentary on the Uncivil Wars”, by Juniper of the Red Shields
From the beginning to end, she was playing an entirely different game than every other commander on the field.
Note how the once-in-a-generation tactician like Juniper – Juniper herself, specifically – is at Cat’s side.
Not because providence, not because of Amadeus’s help. Well, Amadeus provided the support, but it was Catherine who recognized how valuable Juniper was and saw the value of forging an alliance there / recruiting her. And then successfully recruited her.
Positioning!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t think Winter is well suited to cracking open a frozen river. She probably could have done something else instead though.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I gotta say, it seems like Cat came out of the Empire Ever Dark with disappointingly weak results.
The part of the Army of Callow that Cat did meet up with, was the “Third Army,” one of four of Juniper’s columns, and that’s only among those that ventured into Procer. Presumably many Callowan troops have remained in Callow. Let’s say Abigail was heading perhaps an eighth of Callow’s total force, before Cat came to reinforce it.
Now, Cat was supposed to come back with a force that would substantially bolster Callow’s forces – say, coming back with a force 50% as strong as the total Army of Callow would be reasonable to hope for. If that were true, her reinforcements would increase the strength of Abigail’s army by a factor of FIVE. With the odds changing that much, Procer should have been completely routed by overwhelming force, or immediately forced to surrender! Today’s victory was a lot harder won than that, and it shouldn’t have been.
The army Cat brought out of the Night is only five thousand light infantry. The devastating weapons of Night we saw in the Empire Ever Dark, in which plain infantry were mowed like wheat by the powerhouses, were not seen today. No acid fog that melts everyone it touches, for example. It seems that the drow are really just light infantry in daylight. (Remind me, why wasn’t this attack conducted at night?)
So, the drow force is severely disappointing.
In personal power: Cat ran her stamina dry just from breaking the ice under two thousand ordinary foot soldiers. That’s a much weaker working than dropping a lake on a battlefield as she did before, because it requires the soldiers be perfectly arranged over the ice and can’t be done just anywhere. Winter Cat wasn’t even drained by dropping the lake, the only reason she went out of action there was because of heroic intervention. Were it not for them, she could have dropped twenty such lakes.
Winter Cat could have also simply scythed through two thousand ordinary foot soldiers herself in melee combat without breaking a sweat or expending any power. Winter Cat was physically invulnerable and capable of tearing armor like paper with her bare hands. In the absence of heroes, priests, or mages, which seemed fairly absent today, nothing could have stopped her.
Night Cat strikes me as substantially weaker and having less stamina than even the stronger drow under her command. None of the Mighty seemed harmed or exhausted by drawing on Night.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You are not following.
This is a teeny, tiny vanguard of the army from Everark, this force that Cat has brought to Sarcella right now. The rest of it is catching up.
The size of the southern expedition is fifty thousand.
And that’s just the southern expedition, not counting the exodus of the entire population of the drow to the north.
Though this is likely the cream of the crop.
And it’s fifty thousand.
That’s why Cat isn’t worried that the rest of the Levantine army is catching up, too. Time’s on her side here.
LikeLiked by 3 people
It was said that if Cat didn’t get Third Army notified that her drow army were allies, she’d lose roughly a quarter of the Army of Callow.
I assume there’s a caveat there about deployed/deployable/non-garrison forces, since when Juniper split up the Army of Callow, I assume they were roughly equally sized, and I doubt that the entire Army of Callow is in Procer – there’s no doubt detatchments around Summerholm and elsewhere along the Praesi border, and other garrison forces, plus training units.
That said, the six thousand drow that Cat took with her to Sarcella here? They’re an advance force, moving faster than the primary drow army in order to get to Third Army in time, and probably mostly consisting of drow that are least affected/best suited to operating in the day.
IIRC, the primary army is somewhere in the 50k range. There are probably follow-on forces, too, since, well, there are a lot of drow, and if they’re moving out so the dwarves can move in, they (a) need to go somewhere, and (b) a lot of them are going to have combat skills.
This attack was conducted in the day to push the Levantines back across the river, so that Third Army had a more defensible position that would be much easier/near certain to hold until nightfall.
They were seeking to buy the time to get to night, which would allow Third Army to withdraw/the main drow force to arrive and reinforce Third Army.
Before you can act at night, you need to get to night first … while being in striking range of your objective.
We’ve never seen one of the Mighty attempt a significant use of Night in sunlight, either.
Cat has seemed to imply that at night/in the dark her ability to use Night is much stronger than during the day/in sunlight. That’s likely an inherent limitation of Night itself, that would apply to all users, including the Mighty, not just Cat herself.
Winter Cat would not have gated to the other side of the flames – gates are acting oddly, and while that may be a side effect of Winter being absorbed by/merged with Night, that’s not necessarily true, and that may be related to the problems with scrying.
She could have just frozen a path through the flames, though. Or dropped another lake on things.
That said, it is absolutely true that Winter Cat had the sheer power to muscle through most opponents, and fight a lot of the others on near equal ground.
And thus far, Night Cat hasn’t shown anywhere near that level of potential.
On the other hand, Cat and her story had usually been about coming at situations sideways, rather than head on.
On yet another hand … a helluva lot of the drow arc, plus a fair bit of the Keter arc, was about how Cat could better utilize her abilities, figuring out how to do new things with her Winter/Fae powers, and much of that will have been wasted if Night Cat can’t do similar things or otherwise apply what she learned with Winter to Night.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The only problem with ‘learning to better utilize her powers’ is that she’s no longer in control of it. She said as much to Dwarf whatshisname; ‘She doesn’t hold power anymore, only wields it’.
LikeLike
That’s part of why large parts of the Keter and Everdark arcs are in danger of being a waste.
If she can still use Night to do those sorts of things … that will still have been useful, even if she isn’t using her own power to do them.
Unfortunately, it seems that she’ll need prayer to do anything significant, and can’t use Night the way the Mighty she was fighting in the Everdark could, and presumably still can.
LikeLike
This chapter is not, I think, giving proper weight to what the actual fuck Cat pulled off. Remember, this is something Abigail could not achieve with goblin munitions! This was a hella large miracle, of the scale that would have had Winter Cat diving into principle alienation head on.
Smaller tactical stuff she can achieve with minimal support from Komena and Andronike. She didn’t need to pray to them to make her staff, they helped without asking. And the quality of tactical stuff does not depend on its scale, but on its versatility. The Everdark was Catherine figuring out the versatility of her abilities, how they can be used. All of that is still hers, even if there’s now +1 second of delay on using it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Holding and wielding is an academic distinction when Komena and Andronike are trusting Cat’s judgement. Which they are.
LikeLike
Amadeus told us books ago how other black knights were much, much stronger than him. They all still died with much less success to their name because that’s not the thing that’s dangerous about him and it’s the same for cat.
LikeLiked by 1 person
This chapter was almost poetry in how it started.
Dang you are getting good at this! Its like the story of Cat is now woven about her very being, no longer is she just a mortal or named. She is a figure of myth and legend, a maker and breaker of stories, weaver of tales.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I still find Cat’s lack of a Name jarring. Being a priestess of the night or a half fae shouldn’t really exclude that from her prospects. She’s really breaking the Story, isn’t she? Such a powerful figure that for some reason evaded being shackled with a Name.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t think Names are shackles. They’re a coincidental situational bonus that you get if you qualify for it, that tends to stick around and tempt you into getting into more situations that would let you make use of it.
Catherine has finally shaken off the remains of her last situational bonus, and has not yet qualified for a new one. Doesn’t mean she won’t get it, though it won’t matter much at this point. 100d12+10 is just not the same as 2d6+10 :3
LikeLike
The song “Let there be night” (original by Powerwolf, English cover by Kissin Dynamite) seems to be appropriate for Cat wielding a big miracle of Night.
LikeLike
Hot dang. Cat is a walking airstrike in a medieval setting. She is too op.
I’m glad Abigail is going to end up relevant. Been rooting for that since she first appeared. RIP Nauk. But TBH the orc was sort of dead inside already.
LikeLike
I will not ship Cat with every single one of her subordinates, I will not ship Cat with every single one of her subordinates, I will not ship Cat with every single one of her subordinates…
LikeLike